Table 1.
Authors [ref] | Sample | Design | BMI/Weight | Other Outcomes | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
LeCheminant et al. [135] | N=27 men (completers) 20.9 years, BMI 24.4 kg/m2 | Randomized crossover design: 2 wks with no EI between 1900h–0600h, 2 wks eat as usual. 1 wk washout between conditions; food not provided | −0.4 kg with nighttime restriction; +0.6 kg with usual intake | During nighttime restriction, consumed 244 fewer kcals and had greater morning hunger than during usual eating. | |
Hibi et al. [136] | N=11 women, 23 years, BMI 20.6 kg/m2 | Randomized cross-over design, 13d with snack (192 kcal) at 1000h and 13d with same snack at 2300h, plus usual meals (not provided); assessed with respiratory chamber and oral glucose challenge test | No significant difference | Nighttime snack decreased fat oxidation, increased total and LDL cholesterol vs daytime. No differences in glucose and insulin response or energy expenditure. | |
Bo et al. [137] | N=20 (10 men), ages 27.6 years, BMI 23.4 kg/m2 | Randomized crossover design - Single meal manipulation - ate either at 0800h or at 2000h each for 1d, 1 wk apart | Not reported | Glucose, insulin, and free fatty acid response were lower, and resting metabolic rate was higher after morning meal vs evening meal. | |
Bandín et al. [138] | N=22 women, 26 years, BMI 23.2 kg/m2 (Cohort 1) | Randomized crossover design - EE early eating (lunch at 1300h) and LE (lunch at 1630h) for 1 wk each; three meals provided; 1 wk washout between conditions | Not reported | Lower pre-meal resting energy expenditure, fasting carbohydrate oxidation, and glucose tolerance in LE vs EE; no difference in postprandial energy expenditure. | |
Bandín et al. [138] | N=10 women, 26 years, BMI 22.5 kg/m2 (Cohort 2) | Randomized crossover design - EE early eating (lunch at 1300h) and LE (lunch at 1630h) for 1 wk each; three meals provided; 1 wk washout between conditions | Not reported | Decreased thermal effect of food and blunted cortisol profile in LE vs EE. | |
Qin et al. [139] | N=7 (6 men), age 21.7 years, BMI 22.9 kg/m2 | Randomized crossover design for 13d to diurnal - ate at 0700h, 1300h, 1900h with 2230h–0630h sleep-wake cycle, and nocturnal - ate at 1300h, 1900h, and ad lib snacking at night with 0130h–0830h sleep-wake cycle; no food provided, intake estimate of 2,200 - 2,600 kcals | No significant difference | Reduced peaks for melatonin and leptin, and lowered glucose and insulin response to meals in nocturnal vs diurnal eating condition. | |
Yoshizaki et al. [140] | N=14 men, age 21.4 years, BMI 23.1 kg/m2 controls, 21.9 kg/m2 early meal group | All were habitual breakfast skippers - randomized for 2 wks to receive 3 isocaloric meals (provided) either at their usual time: 1300h, 1800h, 2300h or at earlier times: 0800h, 1300h, 1800h | Not reported | Triglycerides, insulin, total and LDL cholesterol decreased in early condition; remained unchanged in usual condition. No difference in glucose, NEFAs, HDL cholesterol, HOMA-IR. | |
Wehrens et al. [51] | N=10 men, age 22.9 years, BMI 23.1 kg/m2 | Within subjects, inpatient study; all received 3 isocaloric meals at 5-h intervals: 1. starting at 0.5h from wake time for 4d, then 2. starting at 5.5h from wake time for 6d, with 37h constant routine assessments after each | Not reported | Delay in mean acrophase of glucose and decreased mean glucose levels in late meals vs early; no differences for timing of sleep, subjective hunger, plasma melatonin, or cortisol. |
Notes: Ages and BMI values are presented as means. BMI - body mass index; wk - week; EI - energy intake; h - hour; d - day; LDL- low-density lipoprotein; EE - early eating; LE - late eating; NEFA - non-esterified fatty acids; HDL - high-density lipoprotein; HOMA-IR - homeostatic model assessment of insulin resistance