Table 3.
Control | HL | CBT | |
---|---|---|---|
Mean (SD) 95% CI | Mean (SD) 95% CI | Mean (SD) 95% CI | |
DASS-21 baseline | |||
Depression | 13.0(13.5) 7.9–18.0 | 15.9(13.5) 10.8–20.9 | 10.8(11.3) 6.6–15.0 |
Anxiety | 11.6(12.6) 6.9–16.3 | 14.0(13.0) 9.1–18.9 | 9.7(10.4) 5.8–13.6 |
Stress | 17.5(14.4) 12.2–22.9 | 18.9(13.6) 13.9–24.0 | 14.2(12.0) 9.7–18.7 |
Total | 42.1(39.0) 27.6–56.7 | 48.8(37.7) 34.7–62.9 | 34.7(30.3) 23.3–46.0 |
DASS-21 3 months | |||
Depression | 9.7(11.6) 5.3–14.0 | 15.8(14.1) 10.5–21.1 | 9.0(10.8) 5.0–13.0 |
Anxiety | 8.7(9.8) 5.1–12.4 | 14.1(14.5) 8.7–19.5 | 7.5(8.5) 4.3–10.6 |
Stress | 14.0(12.9) 9.2–18.8 | 16.7(13.2) 11.8–21.7 | 11.8(10.9) 7.7–15.9 |
Total | 32.4(31.9) 20.5–44.3 | 46.7(39.9) 31.8–61.6 | 34.7(30.3) 23.3–46.0 |
IES-R baseline | |||
Intrusion | 14.8(8.9) 11.5–18.2 | 18.4(9.3) 15.0–21.9* | 12.1(9.4) 8.6–15.6* |
Avoidance | 11.8(8.8) 8.5–15.1 | 15.4(9.1) 11.9–18.7 | 9.9(7.6) 7.1–12.8 |
Hyperarousal | 11.3(6.6) 8.9–13.8 | 13.3(7.5) 10.5–16.1 | 9.2(6.8) 6.6–11.7 |
Total | 37.9(22.9) 29.4–46.5 | 47.1(23.9) 38.1–56.0* | 31.2(22.1) 23.0–39.5* |
IES-R 3 months | |||
Intrusion | 12.7(9.1) 9.3–16.1 | 16.0(10.8) 11.9–20.0* | 9.8(7.5) 7.0–12.6* |
Avoidance | 10.7(8.4) 7.5–13.8 | 13.7(9.7) 10.0–17.3* | 8.0(7.4) 5.3–10.8* |
Hyperarousal | 9.4(7.8) 6.4–12.3 | 11.9(8.1) 8.9–15.0 | 7.3(6.0) 5.3–9.5 |
Total | 32.7(24.0) 23.8–41.7 | 41.6(27.5) 31.3–51.8* | 25.1(19.4) 17.8–32.4* |
These are unadjusted descriptive scores only
CBT cognitive behaviour therapy, DASS-21 Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale 21, HL healthy lifestyle, IES-R Impact of Events Scales (Revised), SD standard deviation
*P < .05