Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 14;18(6):1934. doi: 10.3390/s18061934

Table 5.

Comparisons between the present study and some published work.

Reference Characteristic Features Classifier Number of Classified States Construction Strategy of Training Data Set CA (%)
Zhang et al. [42] Divide time series data into segmentations Deep Neural Networks (DNN) 4 Random selection 94.9
Yao et al. [43] Modified local linear embedding K-Nearest Neighbor (KNN) 4 Random selection 100
Saidi et al. [34] Higher order statistics (HOS) of vibration signals + PCA SVM-OAA 4 Random selection 96.98
Tiwari et al. [5] Multi-scale permutation entropy (MPE) Adaptive neuro fuzzy classifier 4 Random selection +10-fold cross validation 92.5
Zhang et al. [13] Singular value decomposition Multi class SVM optimized by inter cluster distance 3 Random selection 98.54
Present work Weighted permutation entropy of IMFs decomposed by EEMD SVM ensemble classifier + Decision function 3 Random selection 97.78