Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 28;13(6):e0199421. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0199421

Table 1. Descriptive features of 63 studies in the sample.

Feature (reliability) Values (%)
Year of publication (r = .95)
    Mean 2012
    Median 2012
    SD 2.53
Country (κ = .92)
    United States 31 (49.2)
    Spain 5 (7.9)
    South Africa 5 (7.9)
    China 3 (4.8)
    Cuba 3 (4.8)
    United Kingdom 2 (3.2)
    Mexico 1 (1.6)
    Uganda 1 (1.6)
    Trinidad and Tobago 1 (1.6)
    Thailand 1 (1.6)
    Liberia 1 (1.6)
    Nigeria 1 (1.6)
    Panamá 1 (1.6)
    India 1 (1.6)
    Colombia 1 (1.6)
    Canada 1 (1.6)
    Bahamas 1 (1.6)
    South Korea 1 (1.6)
    Puerto Rico 1 (1.6)
Human Development Index
    Very high 40 (63.5)
    High 12 (19)
    Medium 6 (9.5)
    Low 5 (7.9)
Intervention time (κ = 1)
    Less than 4h 7 (14.6)
    4h or more 41 (85.4)
Design
    Randomized control trials 25 (39.7)
    Cluster-randomized control trial 20 (31.7)
    Non-randomized control trial 18 (28.6)
Intervention based on theories (κ = .90) 45 (71.4)
Methodology (κ = 1)
    Passive 4 (7.3)
    Interactive 51 (92.7)
Assessments (in months)
    Short-term
        Mean (SD) 1.03 (1.81)
        Range 0–6
    Medium-term
        Mean (SD) 12.70 (1.99)
        Range 12–18
    Long-term
        Mean (SD) 29.50 (7.54)
        Range 24–40
Goals of the intervention
    HIV 54 (88.5)
    STIs 36 (72)
    Pregnancy 34 (79.1)
    Sexual health promotion 43 (84.3)
Intervention included
    HIV prevention 54 (94.7)
    STIs prevention 35 (77.8)
    Pregnancy prevention 32 (80)
    Male condom 41 (87.2)
    Female condom 3 (10)
    Sexual abstinence 28 (44.4)
    Transmission routes 31 (83.8)
    STIs effects 21 (65.6)
    People living with VIH 13 (52)
    Drugs prevention 8 (26.7)
    Social skills training 16 (53.3)
    Auto-instructions 10 (35.7)
    Emotional management 10 (33.3)
    Self-esteem 9 (29)
Parents’ participation (κ = 1)
    No 54 (85.7)
    Yes 9 (14.3)
School as setting of implementation 55 (94.8)
Participant characteristics (k = 63)
    N at posttest (r = .94)
        Total 38,880
        Mean 1087.69
        Median 784
        SD 1314.41
    % females (r = .98) 58.26
    % sexually active 39.37
    Average age (r = 1)
        Mean 14.96
        Median 15.01
        SD 1.37

k = number of studies; SD = Standard Deviation. Methodology: 1) Passive: When adolescents simply receive instruction through explanatory talks or watching videos, without their participation being pursued; 2) Interactive: Includes strategies to promote the participation of the members of the group (e.g. sharing opinions, dynamic groups, social skills training through role-playing). Emotional management: Refers to the inclusion of strategies for the emotional management (e.g. relaxation, breathing exercises to relax, etc.).