Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 28;13(6):e0199791. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0199791

Table 3. Details of victim identification in individual mass disasters.

Author Year Disaster Disaster subtype Country State/city Total number of victims Number of identified victims (%) Number identified by FO (%) FO used in combination with other methods Other methodologies used for identification
Bastiaan et al. [7] 1984 Natural Bushfires Australia Victoria 72 22 (30.55) 14 (63.63) NA 8
Solheim et al. [8] 1992 Accident Ferry Norway Oslo 158 158 (100) 107 (67.72) NA NA
Brkic et al. [9] 1997 Criminal War Croatia Petrinja 46 27 (58.69) 7 (25.92) NA Personal, 20
Brkic et al. [10] 2000 Criminal War Croatia Slavonia 1000 824 (82.4) 206 (25) 527 Others, 91
Soomer et al. [11] 2001 Accident Ferry Europe Estonia 852 94 (11.03) 57 (60.63) NA NA
Dumanèiæ et al. [12] 2002 Accident Train Croatia Zagreb 152 111 (73.02) 0 6 Fingerprint, 20; Personal, 42; Combination, 49
2002 Accident Air crash Croatia Vrbovec 176 166 (94.31) 0 37 Fingerprint, 6; Personal, 58; Combination, 102
Hutt et al. [13] 2005 Accident Air crash France Strasbourg 87 85 (97.7) 56 (65.88) NA Other, 29
Bux et al. [14] 2006 Accident Air crash Nepal Jomsom 18 14 (77.77) 10 (71.42) FO+Anthropological+Personal, 4 NA
Schuller-Götzburg et al. [15] 2007 Natural Tsunami Thailand Phuket 4280 2679 (62.59) 1105 (41.24) FO+Personal, 206; FO+Fingerprint, 49; FO+Fingerprint+Personal, 64; FO+DNA, 1; FO+Fingerprint+DNA, 1; FO+Fingerprint+Personal+DNA, 3; FO+Personal+DNA, 22 Fingerprint, 670; Fingerprint+DNA, 9; Fingerprint+Personal, 119; Fingerprint+Personal+DNA, 12; DNA, 27; Personal, 6; Personal+DNA, 384; Other, 1
Tan et al. [16] 2007 Accident Air crash Indonesia Southern Sumatra 104 6 (5.7) 2 (33.33) NA Fingerprint, 2; Age, 1; Personal, 1
Prieto et al. [17] 2007 Criminal Terrorist attacks Spain Madrid 191 191 (100) 0 NA DNA, 31; Fingerprint, 145; Combination, 15
Hinchliffe et al. [18] 2009 Natural Bushfires Australian Victoria 173 172 (99.42) 69 (40.11) NA NA
Trengrove et al. [19] 2011 Natural Earthquake New Zealand Christchurch 181 177 (97.79) 58 (32.76) FO+Fingerprint+DNA, 25 DNA, 7; Fingerprint, 76
Physical/visual, 11
Hinchliffe et al. [20] 2011 Accident Air crash USA Kentucky 50 47 (94) 47 (100) NA NA
Bush et al. [21] 2011 Accident Air crash USA Newark 50 50 (100) 38 (76) NA Combination, 12
Manhart et al. [22] 2012 Accident Vehicle Germany Autobahn A19 8 8 (100) 0 0 DNA, 7; Hip implant, 1
Barberia et al. [23] 2015 Accident Train Barcelona Castelldefels Platja station 12 12 (100) 0 0 DNA, 12; Fingerprint, 11
Obafunwa et al. [24] 2015 Accident Air crash Nigeria Lagos 152 148 (97.36) 15 (10.13) DNA+FO, 133 NA
Iino et al. [25] 2015 Natural Tsunami Japan East Japan 15892 15736 (99.01) 1259 (8) NA DNA, 157; Fingerprint, 315; Personal, 14005