Skip to main content
. 2018 May 18;3(3):355–369. doi: 10.1016/j.bioactmat.2018.05.005

Table 1.

Summary of the substrates properties and the cellular responses they evoked.

Grooves/Channels

Material Dimension Cell/tissue Remarks Ref.

Width/Diameter Depth/Height

PMMA 10, 25, 100 μm 330 nm HOBs Decreased nanogroove widths led to increased contact guidance, decreased adhesion and increased angiogenic gene expressions 78,79
2, 3, 6, 12 μm 0.2, 0.5, 1.1, 1.9 μm Baby hamster kidney cells, Increased alignment with increased depth and decreased with increased width. 21,80
PDMS 5, 10, 20, 60 μm 25 μm Human neural stem cell Increased alignment and induced neurite growth with decreased micropattern dimensions. Increased neuron density but altered neurite alignment with increased micropattern dimesions. 81
30 μm 10 μm VEC Orientation along grooves; changes in gene expression 82,83
20–60 μm 11 μm VSMC Enhanced alignment of cell/nuclei on narrow grooves 83,84
20, 50, 80 μm 5, 12 μm VSMC Enhanced cell/nuclei aspect ratio and cell alignment 83,85
3.5 μm 0.2–5 μm VEC Orientation along grooves; no change in proliferation 83,86
2–10 μm 50–200 nm VSMC or VEC Cell orientation and migration along grooves; enhanced cell elongation 19,83
1200 nm 600 nm VEC Increased cell elongation, alignment and migration along grooves and reduced cell proliferation 83,87
600 nm 600 nm Human embryonic stem cells Reduced cell proliferation 21,87
PS 10 μm 3 μm Rat astrocytes Low adhesion, strong alignment 21,88
1–10 μm 0.5–1.5 μm Rat bone marrow cells On large grooves, focal adhesions cover the surface,
On narrow grooves, focal adhesions are only on edges
21,89
1, 2, 5, 10 μm 0.5, 1, 1.5 μm Rat bone marrow cells Better mineralization with 1 μm depth and 1–2 μm width 89
20–1000 nm 5–530 nm Fibroblasts No alignment for depths ˂ 35 nm or widths ˂ 100 nm 21,90
Polyimide 4 μm 5 μm Osteoblasts Strong alignment, no change in adhesion 9,21
PDLA 10 μm 3 μm Schwann cells
(nerve cells)
Strong alignment 21,91
PHBV 1–10 μm 5–30 μm Rat mesenchymal stem cell-derived
osteoblasts
Increased osteoblast adhesion and alignment 79,92
PLGA 350, 700, 1050 nm 500 nm VEC Enhanced adhesion strength,
Increased cell alignment along grooves
83,93
Ti 750 nm- 100 μm 200 nm VEC Increased cell alignment along grooves and higher cell density on grooves with width < 10 μm 83,94
Quartz 0.5,5,10, 25 μm 0.5, 5 μm Murine macrophage Increased orientation 21,95
12.5 μm 5 μm Fibroblasts Change in gene expression profile 21,96
1, 4 μm 1.1 μm MSC Alignment better in the wider grooves 21,97
2–10 μm 30–280 nm Murine macrophage Higher phagocytotic activity when topography size is equal to collagen fiber size 21,98
TCPS 5, 45 μm 5 μm Primary (glioma) and metastatic (lung and colon) tumors Induced migration of primary and metastatic brain, lung and colon cancer cells 99
HA on PET 5, 25 μm Articular knee chondrocytes Induced adhesion, migration, alignment, and differentiation of chondrocytes 79,100
Collagen 27 μm 12 μm Mesenchymal osteoprogenitor cells Cell alignment and enhanced bone formation 53
10 μm 30 μm Human corneal keratocytes and D407 Higher mechanical properties on patterned collagen films 101
650, 500, 332.5 nm 300, 250, 200 nm HMEC No change in proliferation and has a minimal effect on cell alignment, enhanced cell retention under flow-shear conditions 67
Collagen coated with fibrinogen 27 μm 12 μm Rat bone marrow osteoblast cells Enhanced cell orientation and bone formation 102
Ti— coated Si
15 μm
200 nm
T24
Less round and smaller cell shape
21,103
Pillars
Material
Dimension
Cell/tissue
Remarks
Ref.
Width/Diameter
Depth/Height
PMMA 4, 8, 16 μm 8 μm DPSC Control of fate of the stem cells 60
100 nm 160 nm Fibroblasts Smaller, less organized actin cytoskeleton 21,104
100 nm 160 nm Fibroblasts Less spreading 21,105
PLGA 4, 8, 16 μm 8 μm Saos-2, L929, SH-SY5Y, MCF7, hOB Nuclear deformation in cancer cells (Saos-2, MCF-7, SH-SY5Y) not in noncancerous cells (hOB, L929) 58
3 μm 7 μm MSC Geometry of cell nuclei responds to the micropillar array 106
3 μm 5 μm BMSC Severe nucleus deformation, no change in proliferation and differentiation 107
PLGA and PDMS 30 μm 4, 9 μm NIH 3T3 fibroblasts On PDMS, 3T3 cells on stiffer (longer) pillar area. No such effect on PLGA. 108
PDMS 1–5.6 μm 1–8 μm VEC Enhanced cell alignment and elongation on PDMS pillars 109
PDMS coated with fibronectin 10 μm 10 μm MCF-10 A, MDA-MB-231 Epithelial to mesenchymal transition of the breast cancer cells within enclosed micropillar arrays 110
PLLA 2–20 μm
with interpillar spaces 2–20 μm
5–6 μm Saos-2, MG-63, OHS4 Nuclear deformation in cancer cells (Saos-2) higher than in healthy counterparts (OHS-4 and MG-63). Saos-2 cells deformed severely on pillars with 5–10 μm spacing. 111
PLLA, PLLA: PLGA blend 200 nm 900 nm Saos-2, BMSC Saos-2 cells populated fields with pillars 1 μm apart but not on pillar-free surfaces. BMSCs avoided fields with interpillar distances <2 μm. 112
Collagen and PLGA 8, 16 μm 8 μm Saos-2 Increased proliferation and ALP production on collagen micropillars. Increased nuclear deformation on PLGA micropillars 113
Ti 21 nm 15 nm BMSC and hBMHCs Improved bone deposition on nanopillars 114
Alumina
110 nm

Mouse bone marrow stem cells
Increased proliferation and differentiation
21,115
Wells/Pits
Material
Dimension
Cell/tissue
Remarks
Ref.
Width/Diameter
Depth/Height
PMMA 120 nm 100 nm MSC Stimulated differentiation and production of bone mineral in vitro 21,116
35, 75, 120 nm Fibroblasts Reduced adhesion, orientation and distinction of symmetries 21,[117], [118], [119]
PDMS 2, 5, 10 μm Human fibroblasts 2 and 5 μm showed better proliferation
10 μm showed no effect
21,120
PC 7, 25, 50 μm 0.5, 1.5, 2.5 μm Fibroblasts No orientation 21,121
Titanium 100, 30, 10 μm MG63 Cell attachment, growth, aggregation and morphology depends on the presence and dimension of the micropatterns 79,122
PCL 30 μm 80, 220, 333 nm BMSC Optimal adhesion on 80 nm deep pits, inductive capability on 220 nm deep pits 123
150 nm 80 nm Fibroblasts Less focal contacts and vinculin
F-actin cytoskeleton less developed
21,124

*Cells (hOB: primary human osteoblasts, MSC: mesenchymal stem cells, VEC: vascular endothelial cells, VSMC: vascular smooth muscle cells, DPSC: human dental pulp mesenchymal stem cells, HMEC: human microvascular endothelial cells, BMSC: bone marrow stem cells, Saos-2: osteosarcoma cells, MCF-10 A: mammary epithelial cells, MDA-MB-231: breast adenocarcinoma cells, MG63: osteoblast like cells, OHS4: human osteosarcoma cells, L929: mouse fibroblast cell, SH-SY5Y: human neuroblastoma cells, T24: human bladder carcinoma, D407: retinal pigment epithelial cells, hBMHCs: human bone marrow hematopoietic cells).

**Polymers (HA: hyaluronic acid, PET: polyethylene terephthalate, PLLA: poly(l-lactic acid), PMMA: poly(methylmethacrylate), PDMS: polydimethyl siloxane, PLGA: polylactic acid-co-glycolic acid, PCL: polycaprolactone, PC: polycarbonate, PS: polystyrene, PDLA: poly(D,l-lactic acid), PHBV: poly(hydroxybutyrate-co-hydroxyvalerate), TCPS: tissue culture polystyrene).