Table 1.
Paper | N | Ages (years) |
Modality (analysis) |
Model Used | Key Findings of White Matter Microstructural Changes with Age |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||
Perrin 2008 (Perrin et al., 2008) | 408 | 12–18 | T1, MTR (ROI – only CST) | Linear | MTR decrease with age in male adolescents; suggests no major myelin changes in adolescence |
| |||||
Leppert et al, 2009 (Leppert et al., 2009) | 114 | 0–4.5 | T2 relaxometry (ROIs) | Exponential | Rapid, nonlinear decreases of T2 across early childhood in corpus callosum, caudate and thalamus; evidence of posterior-to-anterior progression |
| |||||
Paydar 2014 (Paydar et al., 2014) | 59 | 0–4.6 | DKI, DTI (ROIs) | Exponential | Increases of FA, MK in all ROIs except FA in putamen; largest increases of FA & MK in frontal & parietal WM, ALIC |
| |||||
Dean 2015 (Dean et al., 2015) | 108 | 0.2–5.5 (longitudinal | MWF (ROIs) | Gompertz | Gompertz function – slow, fast, slow |
Sex differences, associations with cognitive abilites | |||||
| |||||
Jelescu 2015 (Jelescu et al., 2015) | 55 | 0–2.75 | WMTI, NODDI (ROIs) | Linear, exponential | Increases of intra-axonal water and tortuosity, trend increase in WMTI but not NODDI fiber alignment in splenium and genu; smaller increases in PLIC |
| |||||
Dean 2016 (Dean et al., 2016) | 18 | 0.25–7.5 | g-ratio (from mcDESPOT & NODDI) | Logarithmic | Decreases throughout brain, continuing across age range |
| |||||
Moura 2016 (Moura et al., 2016) | 176 | 7–14 | MTR (ROIs) and DTI (TBSS, also above in table) | Age bin comparisons | No MTR-DTI correlation; no age-related changes in MTR |
Widespread FA increases and MD and RD decreases, and small clusters where AD decreases | |||||
| |||||
Pangelinan 2016 (Pangelinan et al., 2016) | 941/761 | 12–19 | MTR, T1 | Linear | Decreasing MTR, T1 intensity in male adolescents, but not in females; changes in males are mediated by puberty stage and bioavailable testosterone |
| |||||
Zhang 2016 (Zhang et al., 2016) | 82 | 0.2–15.5 | MT and APT | Exponential | APTW decreasing exponential, MTR increasing exponential |
| |||||
Genc 2017 (Genc et al., 2017a) | 72 | 4–19 | NODDI ROIs | Linear, quadratic, cubic | Widespread increases of NDI; NDI more strongly related to age than any other parameter |
| |||||
Mah 2017 (Mah et al., 2017) | 27 | 8–13 | NODDI | Linear | Widespread increases of NDI; no change in ODI |
Probabilistic tractography |
MTR: magnetization transfer ratio; DKI: diffusion kurtosis imaging; MWF: myelin water fraction; APT: amide proton transfer; NODDI: neurite orientation dispersion and density imaging; NDI: neurite density index; ODI: orientation dispersion index; ROI: region of interest, TBSS: tract based spatial statistics, FA: fractional anisotropy, MD: mean diffusivity, AD: axial diffusivity, RD: radial diffusivity; ILF/SLF: inferior/superior longitudinal fasciculus; UF: uncinate fasciculus; CST: corticospinal tracts