Table 2.
Instrument | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BERNCA Revised (1 study) | Typea | Rank | Centileb | MISSCARE (6 studies) | Type | Rank | Centile | RN4CAST (5 studies) | Type | Rank | Centile |
Emotional & psychological support | p | 1 | 0% | Ambulation three times per day or as documented | u | 1 | 0% | Comfort/talk with patients | p | 1 | 0% |
Assessment of newly admitted patient | u | 2 | 3% | Mouth care | c | 2 | 4% | Educating patients and family | p | 2 | 8% |
Setup care plans | p | 3 | 6% | Attend interdisciplinary care conferences whenever held | P | 3 | 9% | Adequately document nursing care | u | 3 | 17% |
Necessary conversation | p | 4 | 10% | Turning patient every 2hrs | c | 4 | 13% | Oral hygienea | c | 4 | 25% |
Mobilization | u | 5 | 13% | Patient teaching | P | 5 | 17% | Develop or update nursing care plans/care pathways | p | 5 | 33% |
Documentation & evaluation of the care | u | 6 | 16% | Medications administered within 30 min before or after scheduled time | c | 6 | 22% | Frequent changing of patient positiona | c | 5 | 33% |
Activating or rehabilitating care | u | 7 | 19% | Full documentation of all necessary data | u | 6 | 22% | Prepare patients and families for discharge | p | 7 | 50% |
Information about therapies | p | 8 | 23% | Feeding patient when the food is still warm | u | 8 | 30% | Planning care | p | 8 | 58% |
Monitoring of confused patients and use of sedatives | c | 8 | 23% | Assist with toileting needs within 5 min of request | u | 8 | 30% | Adequate patient surveillancea | c | 9 | 67% |
Studying care plans | u | 10 | 29% | Emotional support to patient and/or family | P | 10 | 39% | Administer medications on timea | c | 10 | 75% |
Monitoring patients as the nurse felt necessary | c | 11 | 32% | Assess effectiveness of medications | c | 11 | 43% | Pain managementa | c | 11 | 83% |
Keep patient waiting who rung | u | 12 | 35% | Patient bathing/skincare | c | 12 | 48% | Skin carea | c | 12 | 92% |
Monitoring of confused patients & use of restraints | c | 13 | 39% | Response to call light is provided within 5 min | u | 13 | 52% | Treatments and proceduresa | c | 13 | 100% |
Oral hygiene | c | 14 | 42% | Monitoring intake/output | c | 14 | 57% | ||||
Delay in measure because of a physician delay | u | 15 | 45% | Setting up meals for patients who feed themselves | u | 15 | 61% | ||||
Dental hygiene | c | 16 | 48% | PRN medication requests acted on within 5 min | c | 16 | 65% | ||||
Continence training (diapers) | u | 17 | 52% | IV site care and assessment according to hospital policy | c | 17 | 70% | ||||
Administration of medication, infusions | c | 18 | 55% | Skin/wound care | c | 18 | 74% | ||||
Monitoring patients as prescribed by physician | c | 19 | 58% | Hand washing | c | 19 | 78% | ||||
Skin care | c | 20 | 61% | Ensuring patient discharge planning | P | 20 | 83% | ||||
Change in the position | c | 21 | 65% | Focused reassessment according to patient condition | c | 21 | 87% | ||||
Preparation for discharge | p | 22 | 68% | Patient assessment performed each shift | c | 22 | 91% | ||||
Sponge bath | u | 23 | 71% | Vital signs assessed as ordered | c | 23 | 96% | ||||
Assist food intake | u | 24 | 74% | Bedside glucose monitoring as ordered | c | 24 | 100% | ||||
Education and training | u | 25 | 77% | ||||||||
Adequate hand hygiene | c | 26 | 81% | ||||||||
Partial sponge bath | u | 27 | 84% | ||||||||
Change in wound dressings | c | 28 | 87% | ||||||||
Preparation for test and therapies | c | 29 | 90% | ||||||||
Necessary disinfection measures | c | 30 | 94% | ||||||||
Change in the bed linen | u | 31 | 97% | ||||||||
Continence training (insert catheter) | c | 32 | 100% |
Classification of missed care item: p, planning and communication, c, clinical care, u, unclassified (no consensus).
Percentile rank—the original items were ranked on a scale 1 to n, where n is the number of items on the scale. To ensure comparability in item rankings across scales with different item numbers these are converted to a percentile scale where the highest ranked item (1) is 0% and the highest ranked (n) is 100%.