Table 1.
Study (year) | Journal | Evidence level | Study years | Control group | Number of hips | Mean follow-up (months) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chiu34 2015 | Orthopedics | IV | 1996–2010 | No | 56 | 120 |
Khurana35 2015b | Am J Orthop | III | 2005–2013 | Yes [Primary OA] |
22 | 53 |
Morison36 2016 | Clin Orthop Relate Res | III | 1987–2011 | Yes [Primary OA] |
74 | 96 |
Lizaur-Utrilla37 2012 | J Trauma Acute Care Surg | III | 1992–2005 | Yes [Primary OA] |
24 | 101 |
Zhang38 2011 | J Arthoplasty | IV | 1998–2007 | No | 55 | 64 |
Ranawat39 2009 | J Arthoplasty | IV | 1995–2003 | No | 32 | 56 |
Berry40 2002 | Clin Orthop Relate Res | IV | 1984–1990 | No | 34 | 143 |
Bellabarba41 2001 | J Bone Joint Surg | IV | 1984–1995 | No | 30 | 63 |
Huo42 1999 | J Arthoplasty | IV | 1985–1993 | No | 21 | 65 |
Weber43 1998 | J Bone Joint Surg | IV | 1970–1993 | No | 66 | 115 |
OA: osteoarthritis.
The majority of studies reported both mean postoperative Harris hip score and overall revision rate.
Khurana study included data for femoral neck fractures; we examined only data involving fractures of the acetabulum, which totaled 22 hips.