Table 3.
Type of research | Example of this type of research | Scale, setting and duration of study | CHW to household ratio | System for CHW oversight, training and intervention dissemination |
---|---|---|---|---|
Efficacy research | WASH Benefits Bangladesh study1 | Population; ~ 4169 intervention households; Location: 4 rural sub-districts Duration; 2012–2015 (2-year intervention exposure) |
1:8 CHWs; N = 540 |
CHW oversight; Coordinated by study team (Fig. 3) Transparent and rigorous recruitment criteria and methods Identified as employee to maintain morale and prestige in the community Delivery skills formally assessed Accessible supervision, ~ 12 CHWs/supervisor CHWs received study technologies to encourage CHW and recipient self-efficacy Stipend paid using mobile phone network Training: Provided by project staff Refreshers: scheduled and triggered by fidelity measures Included messages on study staff withdrawal and intervention sustainability Dissemination; Based on communication plan and IBM-WASH theoretical model2 Evaluated messages were understood by recipients Community meetings during roll out for acceptability, expectation management, conflict reduction Sequenced technology and BCC component delivery for combined interventions |
Effectiveness research | Introduction of cholera vaccine in Bangladesh3 | Population; 240,000 Location: urban slums, Dhaka Duration: 2011–2013 (2-year intervention exposure) |
1:290 CHWs; N = 55 |
CHW oversight Single NGO with close project staff involvement, ~ 16 CHWs/supervisor Training Delivered by NGO, developed by project staff Dissemination: NGO-hired CHWs from the local community-delivered interpersonal communications. NGO-delivered hardware |
Implementation research | Sanitation, hygiene Education and water supply in Bangladesh Health Impact Study4 | Population 20 million Location: 58 rural sub-districts Duration: 2007–2012 (4–5-year intervention exposure) |
Up to 1:550 CHWs; N = 10,0005 |
CHW oversight; multiple NGOs; individual NGOs responsible for hiring and supervision Training: multiple NGOs Dissemination: multiple NGO-hired CHWs from the local community, delivered interpersonal communications |
1Arnold et al. [6], www.washbenefits.net; 2Dreibelbis et al. [21]; 3ICVB; the Introduction of Cholera Vaccine in Bangladesh trial [16]; 4SHEWA-B; Sanitation, Hygiene Education and Water supply in Bangladesh Health Impact Study [19]; 5A total of ~ 10,000 CHWs were engaged in dissemination, but not necessarily the full 5-year intervention period
NGO non-governmental organization