Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Sep 1.
Published in final edited form as: Neuroimage. 2017 Jul 11;158:378–396. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.07.008

Table 1.

Test result for atlas-to-image registration.

Deformation Error for each voxel [mm] detJ > 0
Data percentile for all voxels 0.3% 5% 25% 50% 75% 95% 99.7%
Affine 0.0613 0.2520 0.6896 1.1911 1.8743 3.1413 5.3661 N/A
D, velocity, stride 5 0.0237 0.0709 0.1601 0.2626 0.4117 0.7336 1.5166 100%
D, velocity, stride 14 0.0254 0.075 0.1675 0.2703 0.415 0.743 1.5598 100%
D, deformation, stride 5 0.0223 0.0665 0.1549 0.2614 0.4119 0.7388 1.5845 56%
D, deformation, stride 14 0.0242 0.0721 0.1671 0.2772 0.4337 0.7932 1.6805 0%
P, momentum, stride 14, 50 samples 0.0166 0.0479 0.1054 0.1678 0.2546 0.4537 1.1049 100%
D, momentum, stride 5 0.0129 0.0376 0.0884 0.1534 0.2506 0.4716 1.1095 100%
D, momentum, stride 14 0.013 0.0372 0.0834 0.1359 0.2112 0.3902 0.9433 100%
D, momentum, stride 14, 40 epochs 0.0119 0.0351 0.0793 0.1309 0.2070 0.3924 0.9542 100%
D, momentum, stride 14 + correction 0.0104 0.0309 0.0704 0.1167 0.185 0.3478 0.841 100%

The table shows the distribution of the 2-norm of the deformation error of the predicted deformation with respect to the deformation obtained by numerical optimization. Percentiles of the displacement errors are shown to provide a complete picture of the error distribution over just reporting the mean or median errors over all voxels within the brain mask in the dataset. D: deterministic network; P: probabilistic network; stride: stride length of the sliding window for whole image prediction; velocity: predicting initial velocity; deformation: predicting the deformation field; momentum: predicting the initial momentum; correction: using the correction network. The detJ > 0 column shows the ratio of test cases with only positive-definite determinants of the Jacobian of the deformation map to the overall number of registrations (100% indicates that all registration results were diffeomorphic). Our initial momentum networks are highlighted in bold. The best results are also highlighted in bold.