Table 2.
Study | Cohort | Na (M/F) | Testing time | Testing conditions | Outcome measures | Interpretation |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Parker et al. [73] | Collegiate athletes | 20 (8/12) | Within 48 h post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A); tested using motion capture | Gait velocity, stride length, stride time, step width COM ROM and VEL; COM-COP distance |
Decreased dynamic stability in dual-task following concussion: greater ML sway |
Parker et al. [31] | Collegiate athletes | 30 (18/12) | 2, 5, 14, and 28 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A); tested using motion capture | Gait velocity, stride length, step width COM ROM and VEL, COM-COP distance |
More conservative dual-task gait (slower and greater COM-COP distance) 28 d post-concussion compared with controls |
Catena et al. [74] | College students | 28 (16/12) | Within 48 h post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A); tested using motion capture | Gait velocity, stride length, step width COM ROM and VEL, COM-COP distance |
Greater COM motion and velocity during single- and dual-task gait following concussion |
Catena et al. [77] | College students | 28 (16/12) | Not stated | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A), obstacle cross; tested using motion capture | Gait velocity, stride length, step width COM ROM and VEL, COM-COP distance |
Adaptation of conservative gait post-concussion, more in Q&A condition than obstacle cross or single-task gait |
Parker et al. [79] | Collegiate athletes and non-athletes | 56 (N/A) | 2, 5, 14, and 28 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A); tested using motion capture | Gait velocity, COM ROM and VEL, COM-COP distance | Dual-task balance control impairments up to 1 mo following concussion. Athletes walked slower than non-athletes during single/dual-task gait |
Catena et al. [76] | College students | 60 (32/28) | 2, 5, 14, and 28 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A), obstacle cross; tested using motion capture | COM ROM, COM VEL, COM-COP distance | Within 48 h of concussion, conservative single-task gait was observed. By 28 d post-injury, COM motion control during obstacle crossing was observed |
Catena et al. [72] | College students | 20 (10/10) | 2, 6, 14, and 28 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (Stroop); tested using motion capture | COM ROM, COM VEL, Stroop reaction time | Individuals with concussion walked with slower sagittal plane COM motion and displayed attentional capacity deficits compared with controls |
Martini et al. [70] | College students with and without a concussion history | 68 (37/31) | Average of 6.3 y post-concussion for those with a concussion history | Single- and dual-task gait (Brooks-Spatial Memory Task); tested using GaitRITE | Gait velocity, step length, stride width, stance time | Those with a history of concussion walked slower than those without during single-task gait only |
Chiu et al. [78] | Collegiate athletes | 46 (28/18) | Within 48 h of concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A), obstacle cross; tested using motion capture | Obstacle clearance distance, cognitive task accuracy, inter-joint coordination (continuous relative phase) | Participants with concussion walked slower during Q&A and obstacle crossing compared with controls. These conditions also induced greater joint coordination pattern changes for those with a concussion |
Fait et al. [52] | Elite athletes | 12 (8/4) | Average of 37 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (visual Stroop); tested using motion capture | Symptoms, neurocognitive function, maximum gait speed, minimal COM obstacle clearance, response errors, cognitive dual-task costs | No differences between healthy and concussion groups for symptoms or neurocognitive function. Those with a concussion had greater minimal COM obstacle clearance and greater dual-task costs than controls |
Howell et al. [29] | Adolescent athletes | 40 (36/4) | 2, 8, 17, 30, and 59 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (auditory Stroop); tested using motion capture | Symptoms, mean gait velocity, step length, step width, COM ROM, COM VEL, dual-task costs | Symptom resolution occurred for all but 4 concussion subjects by 59 d post-injury. Dual-task COM ROM and VEL and dual-task costs were higher in concussion subjects at 59 d post-injury compared with controls |
Howell et al. [50] | Adolescent athletes | 46 (40/6) | 2, 8, 17, 30, and 59 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (single/continuous auditory Stroop, and Q&A); tested using motion capture | Symptoms, COM ROM, COM VEL, average gait velocity | Symptoms resolved on average within 2 wk of concussion. As task complexity increased, gait stability decreased for the concussion group |
Cossette et al. [98] | Young adult athletes | 21 (9/12) | Average of 158 d post-concussion | Single- and, dual-task gait (Stroop, verbal fluency, arithmetic), and obstacle crossing; tested using motion capture | Average gait velocity, dual-task costs | The concussion group exhibited greater dual-task costs, particularly during obstacle avoidance |
Howell et al. [30] | Adolescent athletes | 38 (32/6) | Before and after return-to-activity clearance | Single- and dual-task gait (auditory Stroop); tested using motion capture | Change across time in COM ROM, COM VEL, average gait velocity, symptoms, attention | During dual-task conditions, frontal plane gait worsened after return to activity for concussion patients. No changes in single-task gait, symptoms, or attention for controls |
Howell et al. [80] | Adolescent and young adult athletes | 76 (52/24) | 2, 8, 17, 30, and 59 d post-concussion | Dual-task gait (auditory Stroop); tested using motion capture | COM ROM, COM VEL, symptoms | Symptoms resolved by 2 wk and 1 mo post-concussion for young adults and adolescents, respectively. Gait balance control deficits were greater for adolescents post-concussion than young adults |
Howell et al. [75] | Adolescent and young adult athletes | 17 (10/7) | 2, 8, 17, 30, and 59 d post-concussion | Dual-task gait (auditory Stroop); tested using an accelerometer | Average gait velocity, peak anterior acceleration, peak medial/lateral acceleration | During dual-task walking, participants with concussion displayed less peak medial–lateral acceleration than control participants during 55–75% of the gait cycle |
Howell et al. [13] | Adolescent and young adult athletes | 29 (21/8) | Average of 58 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (auditory Stroop); tested using motion capture | Time to return to activity, COM ROM, COM VEL, symptoms | A strong correlation exists between time required to return to physical activity and dual-task COM motion at 2 mo post-concussion |
Sambasivan et al. [53] | Physically active children and adolescents | 48 (28/20) | Average of 43 d post-concussion | Single- and dual-task gait (counting backwards by 3 s); tested using GaitRITE, BESS test | Stride width, step length, double support time, BESS errors | Children with concussion show single-task and obstacle cross gait deficits, even after self-reported symptom resolution. No dual-task deficits found |
Fino [51] | Collegiate athletes | 9 (6/3) | Average: 7, 16, 23, 29, 37, 45, and 363 d post-injury | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A); tested using body-worn accelerometers | Gait speed, stride time variability, Lyapunov exponents (local dynamic stability) | The addition of a cognitive dual task influenced stability in the concussed group more than in the control group, despite similar ST stability |
Fino et al. [97] | Collegiate athletes | 8 (2/6) | Average: 7, 16, 23, 29, 37, and 45 d post-injury | Single- and dual-task gait (serial subtraction by 7 s); tested using motion capture | Kinematic turning characteristics | Altered turning kinematics were detected during gait despite absence of clinical deficits |
Howell et al. [81] | Child and adolescent athletes | 68 (28/40) | Average of 9 d post-injury | Single- and dual-task gait (Q&A); tested using body-worn accelerometers | Average gait speed, cadence, double support time, gait cycle duration, stride length | Those with a history of multiple concussions prior to a subsequent concussion displayed smaller DT stride lengths than controls, no difference during ST walking |
Martini et al. [71] | General community | 77 (44/33) | Average of 5.8–48.5 y post-injury | Single- and dual-task gait (Brooks-Spatial Memory Task), obstacle cross, obstacle cross with dual task; tested using motion capture | Gait velocity, step width, stride length, double support time, toe clearance over obstacle | There were no observable gait differences between those with and without a history of concussion occurring during adolescence |
All studies compared post-concussion participants with uninjured control participants, unless otherwise noted
BESS Balance Error Scoring System, COM whole-body center of mass, COP center of pressure, DT dual-task, F female, M male, ML medial-lateral, N/A not available, Q&A question and answer test (spelling words backwards, reciting the months in reverse order, or serial subtraction), ROM range of motion, ST single-task, VEL velocity
N indicates the total sample size (concussion and control groups), broken into total F and M participants