Skip to main content
. 2018 May-Jun;34(3):744–750. doi: 10.12669/pjms.343.15012

Table II.

Methodological quality assessment of included studies based on Coleman Methodology Scoring.28

Study Criteria

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Score Scores (%)
Sfondrini et al. 200430 Yes Yes Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 7/10 70
Cacciafesta et al. 200424 Yes Yes Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 7/10 70
Krishnaswamy et al. 200720 Yes Yes Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 7/10 70
Elekdag-Turk et al. 200831 Yes Yes Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 7/10 70
Koupis et al. 200832 Yes Yes Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 7/10 70
Varlik et al. 200921 Yes Yes No No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 6/10 60
Campoy et al. 201033 Yes Yes No No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 6/10 60
ROMANO et al. 20124 Yes No Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 6/10 60
ROMANO et al. 2012b34 Yes Yes Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 7/10 70
Hammad et al. 201335 Yes Yes No No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 6/10 60
Bovali et al. 201422 Yes Yes No Yes N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No Yes Yes 8/10 80
Jung 201437 Yes No Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 6/10 60
Menini et al. 201423 Yes Yes Yes No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 7/10 70
Ozer et al. 201437 Yes Yes No No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 6/10 60
Vijayakumar et al. 201438 Yes No No No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 5/10 50
Bazargani et al. 201627 Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No Yes Yes 9/10 90
Roelofs et al. 20171 Yes No No No N/A Yes N/A Yes Yes No No Yes 5/10 50

N/A: Not applicable.