Skip to main content
. 2018 Jul 3;9:936. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2018.00936

Table 1.

Summary of studies on nitrogen concentration estimation in crops.

References Species Spectral range Related to Best method Best accuracy (R2)
Tarpley et al., 2000 Cotton 350–1,050 nm LNC Red-edge and near-infrared ratio >0.65
Hansen and Schjoerring, 2003 Winter wheat 438–883 nm LNC 6 principle components 0.71
Stroppiana et al., 2009 Rice 350–2,500 nm PNC NDIopt: (R503-R483)/(R503+R483) 0.65
Li et al., 2010b Winter wheat 350–1,075 nm PNC NDI: (R410-R365)/(R410+R365) 0.57
Tian et al., 2011 Rice 350–2,500 nm LNC Three-band spectral index: R434/(R496+R401) 0.83
Lebourgeois et al., 2012* Sugarcane NIR, R, G, B LNC SRPIb 0.70
Cao et al., 2013 Rice NIR, RE, G PNC REGDVI: red edge green difference vegetation index 0.33
Feng et al., 2014 Winter wheat 350–2,500 nm LNC (R755+R680-2 × RREPig)/(R755-R680) 0.85
Yao et al., 2015 Winter wheat 350–2,500 nm LNC SVM with first derivative canopy spectra 0.78
Schirrmann et al., 2016* Winter wheat R, G, B PNC Ratio of the red and green channel 0.68
Liu et al., 2017* Winter wheat 450–950 nm LNC Back Propagation (BP) neural network methods 0.97
Van Der Meij et al., 2017* Oat 400–950 nm PNC Simple difference (780 nm – 765 nm) 0.68

The references are indexed by the year of publication and summarized with the species examined, the spectral range of the reflectance data, the expression of nitrogen concentration, the analytical method, and the best result within each study. The UAV studies were marked with *.

NIR, RE, R, G, and B represent near infrared, red edge, red, green and blue bands, respectively.