Table 1.
Reference | Study Design | Country | Population | Intervention | Sample size by Intervention / Control | Measurement for Adherence | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stuurman-Bieze et al. 2014
PMID: 24570297 |
Open-label Clinical Trial with Historical Controls | Holland | Patients starting osteoporosis medications | MeMO program: pharmacist-delivered medication monitoring and counseling | Intervention (N = 495) Historical control (N = 442) |
Therapy discontinuation and adherence at 12 months | Intervention: 19.0% discontinued medications or were non-adherent Control: 32.8% discontinued medications or were non-adherent; (p< 0.001) |
Ganda et al. 2014
PMID: 24445732 |
Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial | Australia | Patients over age 45 with symptomatic fragility fractures | “Type A” FLS program in Group A Intervention (6 visits with FLS); | Intervention (N = 49)
Control (N = 53) |
Medication possession ratio (MPR) at 24 months | Intervention: MPR = 0.78 (IQR, 0.50–0.93) Control: MRP = 0.79 (IQR, 0.48– 0.96); (p=0.68) |
Dehamchia-Rehailia et al. 2014
PMID: 24980182 |
Open-label Clinical Trial | France | Patients with low-trauma fractures | “Type A” FLS program | Intervention (N = 335) | Self-reported medication adherence at 12 and 18 months | Intervention: 74.1% adherent at 12 months; 67.4% adherent at 18 months |
Majumdar et al. 2017
PMID: 28275838 |
Open-label Clinical Trial with a Simulated Control Group | Canada | Patients with low trauma non-hip fractures in the previous 6 weeks | Catch-a-Break: “Type C” FLS program | Intervention (N = 4633) Simulated control (N = 2690) |
Bisphosphonate use at 12 months | Intervention: 17.5% (95% CI 15.6–19.4) treated with bisphosphonates Simulated Control: 13.2% (95% CI 12.4–14.0) treated with bisphosphonates; (p < 0.001) |
Sewerynek et al. 2013
PMID: 23671440 |
Non-randomized Controlled Clinical Trial | Poland | Postmenopausal osteoporosis patients on alendronate | Osteoporosis education (Counseling group); patient notification of laboratory results (Biochemical group); phone call to remind about medication (Nurse-assisted group) |
Counseling group (N = 29) Biochemical group (N = 31) Nurse-assisted group (N = 31) Control group (N = 32) |
Medication Compliance (MPR ≥ 80%) at 12 months | Counseling group: 65.52 ± 9.0%
Biochemical group: 64.51 ± 8.7% Nurse-assisted group: 61.29 ± 9.0% Control group: 37.5 ± 8.7% |
Tüzün et al. 2013
PMID: 24324365 |
Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial | Turkey | Postmenopausal women with osteoporosis | Telephone calls, interactive educational sessions, informational booklets | Intervention (N = 226)
Control (N = 222) |
Self-reported persistence and compliance at 12 months | Intervention: Self-reported persistence and compliance = 152 (50.5) Control: Self-reported persistence and compliance = 149 (49.5); (p = 0.862) |
Solomon et al. 2012
PMID: 22371876 |
Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial | U.S. | Patients starting osteoporosis medications | Telephone-based counseling program by a health educator | Intervention (N = 1046)
Control (N = 1041) |
Medication possession ratio (MPR) at 12 months | Intervention: MPR = 49% (IQR 7, 88)
Control: MPR = 41% (IQR 1.5, 86.0); (p = 0.074) |
Nho et al. 2016
PMID: 27294076 |
Non-randomized Controlled Clinical Trial | Korea | Patients with osteoporosis | Alarm clock | Intervention (N = 50)
Control (N = 50) |
Medication possession ratio (MPR) at 12 months | Intervention: MPR = 0.80 ± 0.33 Control: MPR = 0.56 ± 0.34; (P<0.001) |
Cizmic et al. 2015
PMID: 25956282 |
Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial | U.S. | Adults with osteoporosis / osteopenia | Interactive voice response phone call followed by a reminder letter to prompt | Intervention (N = 126)
Control (N = 118) |
Proportion of patients who purchased oral bisphosphonates within 25 days of randomization | Intervention: 48.8% patients purchased their oral bisphosphonates Control: 30.5% patients purchased their oral bisphosphonate |
Bianchi et al. 2015
PMID: 25619634 |
Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial | Italy | Postmenopausal women starting osteoporosis treatment | Educational booklets, calendar, alarm clock (Group 2) Phone call reminders and the materials for Group 2 (Group 3) | Group 2 (N = 110)
Group 3 (N = 111) Control (N = 113) |
Proportion of patients persistent to treatment (taking the drug for ≥80% of time) at 12 months | Group 2: 90.1% persistent
Group 3: 84.6% persistent Control: 92.0% persistent; (p=0.288) |
MeMO, Medication Monitoring and Optimization program; MPR, Medication Possession Ratio; PCP, Primary Care Physician.
Patient-directed interventions: Behavioral Interventions using Counseling/Coaching, Interventions using medication reminder prompts
Healthcare system interventions: Pharmacist-directed and Fracture Liaison Service