TABLE III. B-Line Identification Performance*.
score | method | STICK [17] | HOUGH [21] | AWBF [14] | proposed =2, =1 | proposed =1, =1 | proposed =0.5, =0.5 | proposed =1, =0.1 | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
w/o | w | w/o | w | w/o | w | w/o | w | |||||
AFT [8] | 0.63±0.22 | 0.64±0.24 | 0.64±0.21 | 0.64±0.22 | 0.67±0.22 | 0.66±0.20 | 0.71±0.21 | 0.73±0.19 | 0.81±0.22 | 0.75±0.20 | 0.82±0.19 | |
ASF [9] | 0.66±0.25 | 0.62±0.19 | 0.65±0.24 | 0.67±0.21 | 0.68±0.21 | 0.70±0.20 | 0.69±0.23 | 0.70±0.22 | 0.87±0.18 | 0.70±0.20 | 0.87±0.19 | |
proposed | 0.68±0.23 | 0.74±0.20 | 0.71±0.22 | 0.74±0.19 | 0.85±0.19 | 0.78±0.18 | 0.87±0.19 | 0.93±0.16 | 0.97±0.15 | 0.89±0.19 | 0.97±0.16 | |
AFT [8] | 0.69±0.23 | 0.68±0.23 | 0.69±0.27 | 0.71±0.22 | 0.74±0.20 | 0.73±0.21 | 0.77±0.19 | 0.77±0.22 | 0.76±0.20 | 0.78±0.21 | 0.74±0.21 | |
ASF [9] | 0.72±0.28 | 0.67±0.23 | 0.69±0.24 | 0.73±0.20 | 0.74±0.21 | 0.75±0.19 | 0.75±0.21 | 0.75±0.20 | 0.79±0.21 | 0.74±0.21 | 0.81±0.18 | |
proposed | 0.74±0.21 | 0.73±0.20 | 0.74±0.28 | 0.80±0.19 | 0.88±0.17 | 0.83±0.18 | 0.89±0.17 | 0.94±0.17 | 0.94±0.18 | 0.91±0.19 | 0.92±0.17 | |
AFT [8] | 0.77±0.27 | 0.72±0.24 | 0.74±0.29 | 0.80±0.22 | 0.83±0.21 | 0.82±0.20 | 0.84±0.18 | 0.82±0.20 | 0.71±0.22 | 0.80±0.22 | 0.67±0.26 | |
ASF [9] | 0.81±0.25 | 0.73±0.20 | 0.77±0.24 | 0.81±0.20 | 0.83±0.23 | 0.80±0.19 | 0.81±0.18 | 0.81±0.19 | 0.72±0.21 | 0.78±0.19 | 0.75±0.20 | |
proposed | 0.81±0.25 | 0.75±0.20 | 0.78±0.23 | 0.88±0.20 | 0.92±0.17 | 0.88±0.19 | 0.91±0.17 | 0.96±0.14 | 0.90±0.16 | 0.93±0.18 | 0.88±0.19 |
mean±standard deviation