Skip to main content
. 2018 Jul 16;9:1425. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2018.01425

Table 3.

Analysis of variance (two-way ANOVA) for the measured biological parameters as affected by soil origin (O), sampling site (S) and their interactions (O × S).

Parameter Source of variation df Sum of squares Mean square Variance explained (%) F P
MICROBIAL COUNTS
Oligotrophic bacteria (10 % TSBA + nystatin) Origin (O) 4 9.95 2.49 69.05 479.98 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 0.87 0.43 6.02 83.73 <0.001***
O × S 8 3.44 0.43 23.85 82.91 <0.001***
Zinc-tolerant bacteria (10 % TSBA + 1.5 mM Zn2+ + nystatin) Origin (O) 4 8.41 2.10 41.84 41.39 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 6.05 3.02 30.10 59.55 <0.001***
O × S 8 4.11 0.51 20.48 10.13 <0.001***
Cadmium-tolerant bacteria (10 % TSBA + 0.5 mM Cd2+ + nystatin) Origin (O) 4 13.21 3.30 25.88 37.21 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 24.47 12.24 47.96 137.91 <0.001***
O × S 8 10.68 1.34 20.94 15.05 <0.001***
Fungi (PDA + Rose Bengal + streptomycin) Origin (O) 4 2.37 0.59 48.26 41.89 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 0.54 0.27 10.95 19.01 <0.001***
O × S 8 1.58 0.20 32.16 13.96 <0.001***
PLFA
Total PLFA biomass Origin (O) 4 23,178.72 5,794.68 36.05 17.17 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 17,749.87 8,874.93 27.61 26.29 <0.001***
O × S 8 13,233.07 1,654.13 20.58 4.90 <0.001***
Bacterial PLFA biomass (BB) Origin (O) 4 3,709.42 927.36 41.83 18.09 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 1,520.76 760.38 17.15 14.83 <0.001***
O × S 8 2,099.19 262.40 23.67 5.12 <0.001***
Gram-positive bacteria PLFA biomass (GP) Origin (O) 4 500.95 125.24 26.51 7.69 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 550.03 275.02 29.11 16.89 <0.001***
O × S 8 350.20 43.77 18.53 2.69 0.023*
Gram-negative bacteria PLFA biomass (GN) Origin (O) 4 1,362.35 340.59 51.74 34.49 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 200.87 100.43 7.63 10.17 <0.001***
O × S 8 773.77 96.72 29.38 9.79 <0.001***
GP:GN ratio Origin (O) 4 0.06 0.02 3.52 1.12 0.364
Sampling site (S) 2 0.94 0.47 54.43 34.75 <0.001***
O × S 8 0.32 0.04 18.55 2.96 0.014*
Actinomycetes PLFA biomass Origin (O) 4 26.73 6.68 26.82 19.26 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 50.31 25.16 50.50 72.52 <0.001***
O × S 8 12.19 1.52 12.23 4.39 0.001**
Fungal PLFA biomass (FB) Origin (O) 4 131.08 32.77 59.62 95.20 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 47.09 23.54 21.42 68.40 <0.001***
O × S 8 31.37 3.92 14.27 11.39 <0.001***
BB:FB ratio Origin (O) 4 1,129.17 282.29 44.86 107.88 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 542.08 271.04 21.54 103.58 <0.001***
O × S 8 767.19 95.90 30.48 36.65 <0.001***
BIOLOG-CLPP
∑AUC Origin (O) 4 1,379,281.030 344,820.258 34.83 135.607 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 1,394,786.201 697,393.100 35.22 274.263 <0.001***
O × S 8 1,109,553.371 138,694.171 28.02 54.544 <0.001***
H' Origin (O) 4 0.581 0.145 21.51 5.810 0.001**
Sampling site (S) 2 0.379 0.190 14.05 7.588 0.002**
O × S 8 0.989 0.124 36.67 4.951 0.001**
Rs Origin (O) 4 84.089 21.022 15.94 3.403 0.021*
Sampling site (S) 2 59.511 29.756 11.28 4.817 0.015*
O × S 8 198.711 24.839 37.66 4.021 0.002**
Eh Origin (O) 4 0.022 0.005 21.72 4.76 0.004**
Sampling site (S) 2 0.014 0.007 13.99 6.13 0.006**
O × S 8 0.030 0.004 30.06 3.29 0.008**
DGGE
H' Origin (O) 4 0.8251 0.2063 76.10 302.0 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 0.1158 0.0579 10.68 85.0 <0.001***
O × S 8 0.1228 0.0154 11.33 22.0 <0.001***
Rs Origin (O) 4 2,940.8 735.2 60.83 624.2 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 872.1 436.1 18.04 370.2 <0.001***
O × S 8 986.5 123.3 20.40 104.7 <0.001***
Eh Origin (O) 4 0.0047 0.0012 43.63 63.0 <0.001***
Sampling site (S) 2 0.0015 0.0007 13.76 40.0 <0.001***
O × S 8 0.0040 0.0005 37.45 27.0 <0.001***

H', Shannon-Wiener biodiversity index; Rs, richness; Eh, evenness. Asterisks represent significance level according to ANOVA (

*

P < 0.05,

**

P < 0.01 and

***

P < 0.001).