Table 1.
Overview of Studies Included in Reviewa
Study | Journal (Year) | LOE | Sex (Age) | Sporting Activity | Injury Mechanism | Tear Location | Complete vs Partial Tear | Treatment | Return to Sport, mo | Complications |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lempainen21 | Br J Sports Med (2007) | 4 | M (40) | Ice hockey | NR | Avulsion | Complete | Surgery | 2 | None |
M (27) | Floorball | NR | MTJ | Complete | Surgery | 3 | None | |||
M (24) | Track | Sprinting | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 5 | None | |||
M (20) | Track | Long jumping | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 3 | None | |||
M (24) | Track | Sprinting | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 4 | None | |||
M (40) | Marathon | Sprinting | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 4 | None | |||
M (24) | Soccer | Kicking, knee hyperextension | Tendinous | Partial | Surgery | 5 | None | |||
M (18) | Track | Sprinting | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 2 | None | |||
M (29) | Triathlon | Sprinting | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 5 | None | |||
F (24) | Road cycling | NR | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 3 | None | |||
M (18) | Track | Sprinting | MTJ | Partial | Surgery | 2 | None | |||
Pan26 | Med J Malaysia (2000) | 5 | M (33) | Soccer | Kicking, knee hyperextension | Avulsion | Complete | Surgery | NR | Seroma requiring exploration |
McGoldrick25 | Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (1990) | 5 | M (36) | Cricket | Running, knee hyperextension | MTJ | Complete | Surgery | NR | None |
Sebastianelli28 | Clin Orthop Relat Res (1990) | 5 | M (21) | Football | Trauma, knee hyperextension, valgus load | Avulsion | Complete | Surgery | 6 | None |
Rehm27 | Unfallchirurg (2009) | 5 | M (27) | Soccer | Running, knee hyperextension | Avulsion | Complete | Surgery | 6 | None |
Kusma19 | Arch Orthop Trauma Surg (2007) | 5 | M (43) | Soccer | Kicking, knee hyperextension | Avulsion | Complete | Surgery | 6 | None |
Werlich35 | Unfallchirurg (2001) | 5 | M (37) | Soccer | Kicking, knee hyperextension | Avulsion | Complete | Surgery | 12 | None |
Valente32 | Musculoskelet Surg (2013) | 5 | M (24) | Football | Trauma, knee hyperextension, valgus load | MTJ | Complete | Surgery | 12 | None |
Verburg33 | Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd (1991) | 5 | M (50) | Water-skiing | Fall over wave, knee hyperextension | MTJ | Complete | Surgery | 3 | None |
Jensen18 | Scand J Med Sci Sports (1994) | 5 | M (35) | Soccer | Kicking, knee hyperextension | MTJ | Complete | Surgery | 3 | None |
M (30) | Soccer | Kicking, knee hyperextension | MTJ | NR | Conservativeb | 0.75 | None | |||
Fortems17 | Injury (1995) | 5 | M (44) | Indoor soccer | Kicking, knee hyperextension | MTJ | Complete | Conservativec | 4 | None |
aF, female athlete; LOE, level of evidence; M, male athlete; MTJ, tears to the musculotendinous junction; NR, not reported.
bAthlete declined surgery at the urging of the team.
cAthlete refused surgery.