Table 4.
Authors and date Sample size | Sample Setting Country | Intervention | Study design | Outcomes in aspects of the self and quantitative measurements Study aim and qualitative methods | Results in aspects of the self | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Content Control group (CG) treatment | Duration Frequency | |||||
(A) CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS | ||||||
Backe and Graefe, 2004 N = 9 |
Female children with lack of self-esteem; age: 8–10 years University, movement outpatient clinic (“Bewegungs-ambulatorium”) Germany |
Educational dance/creative dance | 12 weeks 1 day a week, 90 min per session, final presentation |
Pilot study; empirical experimental method & qualitative phenomenological approach; pre-post-test design; no control | Self-esteem (Aussageliste zum Selbstwertgefühl; Schauder, 1991) Investigation of an interaction between self-esteem and movement behavior and general behavior by observations | Improvement of global self-esteem in 7 of 9 girls, but no calculation of significance. Parents and teachers rated self-esteem higher at post-test compared to pre-test and the girls' self-evaluations. Support of the hypothesis of a correlation between movement behavior change and increase of self-esteem by qualitative observations. |
Caf et al., 1997 N = 16 |
Hypoactive children with learning difficulties (10 female, 6 male); age: 7–10 years Primary school Slovenia |
Creative movement and dance CG: no participation in any optional activity outside of the ordinary classroom schoolwork | 16 weeks 1 day a week, 60 min per session |
Pilot study; empirical experimental method & action research approach; pre-post-test design; no randomization for experimental (N = 8) and control (N = 8) | Body image (Body Image Evaluating Scale; Cratty, 1979) Investigation of the children's behavior activities and qualities in different categories, e.g., body image, by observations and teacher diary notes |
Improvement in the tasks “body sides” and “objects” for experimental group in body image. No presentation of results in terms of body image from the qualitative observations. |
(B) ADULTS | ||||||
Stickley et al., 2015 N = 330 |
Adults (of 34 dance classes); age: wide age range, no precise information Rural community venue UK |
Community-based dance activities with a range of dance styles | 30 months (attendance of at least 8 individual classes for inclusion in analysis) | Post-test design: questionnaire after 8–10 weeks (providing questionnaire N = 602, response rate 55%); focus group discussions with 13 participants immediately after dance sessions; interviews among 7 participants; no control | Attitudes about health and well-being with a question about self-expression (Stickley et al., 2015) Investigation of reasons for participating and the gained benefits of participating in dance sessions by focus group discussions and individual interviews |
57% agreed with the statement of an increased ability to express themselves (42.1% neutral; 1% disagree). Key topics of the focus group discussions and individual interviews: development of a feeling “like you've achieved something” (self-efficacy) and a “gain [of] confidence” (self-confidence), “expressing yourself” (self-expression). |