Skip to main content
. 2018 Jul 17;9:1130. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01130

Table 4.

Framework conditions of the mixed methods studies.

Authors and date Sample size Sample Setting Country Intervention Study design Outcomes in aspects of the self and quantitative measurements Study aim and qualitative methods Results in aspects of the self
Content Control group (CG) treatment Duration Frequency
(A) CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS
Backe and Graefe, 2004
N = 9
Female children with lack of self-esteem; age: 8–10 years
University, movement outpatient clinic (“Bewegungs-ambulatorium”) Germany
Educational dance/creative dance 12 weeks
1 day a week, 90 min per session, final presentation
Pilot study; empirical experimental method & qualitative phenomenological approach; pre-post-test design; no control Self-esteem (Aussageliste zum Selbstwertgefühl; Schauder, 1991) Investigation of an interaction between self-esteem and movement behavior and general behavior by observations Improvement of global self-esteem in 7 of 9 girls, but no calculation of significance. Parents and teachers rated self-esteem higher at post-test compared to pre-test and the girls' self-evaluations.
Support of the hypothesis of a correlation between movement behavior change and increase of self-esteem by qualitative observations.
Caf et al., 1997
N = 16
Hypoactive children with learning difficulties (10 female, 6 male); age: 7–10 years
Primary school Slovenia
Creative movement and dance CG: no participation in any optional activity outside of the ordinary classroom schoolwork 16 weeks
1 day a week, 60 min per session
Pilot study; empirical experimental method & action research approach; pre-post-test design; no randomization for experimental (N = 8) and control (N = 8) Body image (Body Image Evaluating Scale; Cratty, 1979)
Investigation of the children's behavior activities and qualities in different categories, e.g., body image, by observations and teacher diary notes
Improvement in the tasks “body sides” and “objects” for experimental group in body image.
No presentation of results in terms of body image from the qualitative observations.
(B) ADULTS
Stickley et al., 2015
N = 330
Adults (of 34 dance classes); age: wide age range, no precise information
Rural community venue UK
Community-based dance activities with a range of dance styles 30 months (attendance of at least 8 individual classes for inclusion in analysis) Post-test design: questionnaire after 8–10 weeks (providing questionnaire N = 602, response rate 55%); focus group discussions with 13 participants immediately after dance sessions; interviews among 7 participants; no control Attitudes about health and well-being with a question about self-expression (Stickley et al., 2015)
Investigation of reasons for participating and the gained benefits of participating in dance sessions by focus group discussions and individual interviews
57% agreed with the statement of an increased ability to express themselves (42.1% neutral; 1% disagree).
Key topics of the focus group discussions and individual interviews: development of a feeling “like you've achieved something” (self-efficacy) and a “gain [of] confidence” (self-confidence), “expressing yourself” (self-expression).