Skip to main content
. 2018 Jul 25;26:30. doi: 10.1186/s12998-018-0198-7

Table 1.

Descriptive checklist of eight clinical research studies plus one clinically relevant research study on Functional Neurology approach included in a critical review

1st Author Year Journal Topic covered Study subjects:-Type
-Age (range)
-Origin
-Number (males/females)
-Intervention
-Control (other than sham)
-Sham
-Outcome
-How was it assessed?
When was it assessed? Ethics approval? (with a clear mention of its origin) Conflict of interest (reported or supposed)
Malkowicz
2006 [20]
Intern J Neuroscience
Cortical visual impairment Intervention group
-Pediatric patients diagnosed with cortical visual impairment
−13-120 months -Selected from a clinical database
−21 (?/?)
Control group
-Patients diagnosed with cortical visual impairment
-?
-Unclear
− 67 (?/?)
-Individualized at-home intensive visual program, during 4–15 months
-Retrospective control sample from a previous published study, probably on the natural course
-None
-Visual level
-Developmental profile (an evaluation tool, proper to the clinic from where the patients were recruited, which included a visual scale)
-Before
-Follow-ups at least every 6 months if treatment lasted that long (only for intervention group, no exact time of follow-up(s) was given for the external control group)
Unclear No mention about any potential conflict of interest
Daubeny
2010 [21]
Int J Disabil Hum Dev
Brain function Intervention group
-Healthy adults
-(?-?)
-?
− 31 (?/?)
Control group
-Healthy adults
-(?-?)
-?
− 31 (?/?)
−10 upper extremity manipulations
-None
-Upper extremity sham manipulations with unloaded activator instrument
-Blind-spot size
-Blind-spot measurement
-Before
-Immediately after
Unclear Authors reported to have no competing interests
However, at least 2 authors are known to have business interest in relation to the topic.
Leisman
2010a [22]
Int J Disabil Hum Dev
Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorders Intervention group 1
-Children with ADHD
− 6-11 years
-Several clinics
− 36 (36/0)
Intervention group 2
-“Normal” children
-Age-matched with the ADHD group
-?
− 15 (15/0)
Control group 1
-Children with ADHD
− 6-11 years
-Several clinics
− 42 (42/0)
Control group 2
-“Normal” children
-Age-matched with the ADHD group
-?
− 16 (16/0)
-Motor sequencing training, 3-month course
-No motor sequencing training
-None
-Signal detection performance
-Signal detection task
-Before
-After
No information was found No mention about any potential conflict of interest
However, at least 1 author is known to have a business interest in relation to the topic.
Leisman
2010b [23]
Int J Adolesc Med Health
Attention deficit-disorders/Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorders -Child patients with ADD/ADHD
−6-12 years
-Clinics (said to be associated with one of the authors)
−122 (94/28)
−12-weeks individualized hemispheric specific remediation program, 3 times/week, 1 h each (i.e. 36 sessions)
-None
-None
1- Sensory and motor function
2- Academic performance
3- Behaviors
1- Functional assessments of sensory and motor function 2- Wechsler Individual Achievement Tests
3- Brown Attention Deficit Disorders Scales
-Before
-After
No information was found Yes, 1 is reported:
Patients came from clinics where 3 of the authors have financial interest in the topic.
In addition, the project was funded by an institution with known financial interest in the area.
Carrick 2011 [16]
Funct Neurol Rehabil Ergon
Balance -Adults
−24-52 years
-?
−25 (16/9)
-Whole body rotation over 40 s
-None
-None
-Stability and sway
-Dynamic computerized posturography system (CAPS™ Professional System)
-Before
-After
Unclear Yes, 1 is reported:
Two authors “are currently employed and are part owners of the Vestibular Technologies, LLC”
In addition, the project was funded by an institution with known financial interest in this area.
Castellanos
2012 [24]
Funct Neurol Rehabil Ergon
Stated in title: traumatic brain injury but according to Methods: stroke Intervention group
-Adult patients
with traumatic brain injury
− 18-51 years
-?
− 15 (?/?)
Control group
-Healthy volunteers age and gender-matched
-Age-matched with the intervention group
-?
− 14 (?/?)
-Individualized neuropsychological rehabilitation, 3–4 times/week for 1 h/session, during 7–12 months
+/− associated with physiotherapy, speech therapy, and/or occupational therapy
-“Control group” at baseline only (healthy subjects were not subjected to any intervention)
-None
-Complexity and entropy of brain activity
-Magneto-encephalography
-Before
-After (only for intervention group, control group was assessed only at baseline)
Unclear No mention about any potential conflict of interest
Carrick
2013 [17]
Funct Neurol Rehabil Ergon
Balance Study 1:
-Healthy adult volunteers
−20-60 years
-Recruited from advertisements
−52 (31/21)
Study sample was randomly allocated to 4 groups, details regarding age (range) and gender were not given for each of them.
Study 2:
-Healthy adult volunteers
− 20-61 years
-Recruited from advertisements
− 56 (33/23)
Study sample was randomly allocated to 4 groups, details regarding age (range) and gender were not given for each of them.
Both studies:
-Whole body rotation over 40 s for all groups
-Each group (4 per study) differed in terms of pitch and yaw planes during whole body rotation
-None
Study 1:
-Eight posturographic measures
Study 2:
-Six poturographic measures
Both studies:
-Dynamic computerized posturography system (CAPS™Professional System)
Both studies:
-Before
-Immediately after
− 1 day after
−1 week after
Unclear No mention about any potential conflict of interest
However, at least 1 author is known to have a business interest in relation to the topic. Another 2 have/had a financial interest in the posturography equipment [16].
Sullivan
2013 [18]
Funct Neurol Rehabil Ergon
Migraine Intervention group
-Female adult patients or volunteers, all in midst of a migraine attack
− 15-53 years
-Referred from local medical clinics or recruited from advertisements
− 13 (0/13)
Control group
-Female adult patients or volunteers, all in midst of a migraine attack
− 25-38 years
-Referred from local medical clinics or recruited from advertisements
− 3 (0/3)
-Pneumatic ear insufflation, provided in roughly 30s intervals with a minimum of 3 insufflations
-None
-Otoscope with insufflation speculum with no pneumatic pressure applied
-Pain
-Visual analog scale
-Before
-During (after each insufflation)
-30 min after
-4 h after
-24 h after
Unclear No mention about any potential conflict of interest
Bousquet
2015 [19]
Funct Neurol Rehabil Ergon
Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorders /Autism-spectrum disorders -Student volunteers with ADHD or ADS (identified with a “right-hemisphere weaknesses”)
-Hemisphere integration therapy tutoring center
− 7-16 years
− 12 (10/2)
-Individualized hemisphere integration therapy, 36 individual/group sessions, 3 times/week, 1 h each, combined with nutritional training and home exercises
-None
-None
1-Self-perception of academic, sensory, and motor abilities
2-Behavior
3-Cognitive skills
4-Senrory and motor skills
1-Semi-structured interviews
2-Brown Attention Deficit Scales / Gilliam Autism Rating Scales / Gilliam Asperger’s Syndrome Scales
3-Wechsler Individual Achievement Test III
4-Perdue Pegboard performance / Dichotic Word Listening Test / Aerobic, core and balance exercises
-Before
-After
No information was found No mention about any potential conflict of interest

ADHD Attention deficit and hyperactivity disorders, ADD Attention deficit disorders, ASD Autism-spectrum disorders