Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 21;18(7):1983. doi: 10.3390/s18071983

Table 2.

Literature review of traffic accident prevention and avoidance schemes based on Routing Schemes.

Authors Proposed Scheme Name Proposed Scheme Methodology Issues Identified Benefits Scalability Issue Simulation Tool
Rajesh-Kumar et al. [21] Distance Based routing scheme The scheme obtains the vehicle location and calculates the distance of the vehicle that is near to the intersection.
After calculating the location, the vehicle with the shortest distance to the intersection will send an alert to the other vehicles about its distance and location.
All other vehicles will be alerted about the upcoming vehicle and are protected from the traffic accident
Possibilities presented at the intersection.
Timeliness of alert messages
Less traffic congestion
Maximum Packet Delivery Ratio.
Yes NS-2.34
Nzouonta et al. [24] Spatio-Temporal Emergency Information Dissemination (STEID) The routing scheme satisfies both temporal and spatial reliability by guaranteeing the delivery of an alert message in a short interval
The message passes to all the vehicles that are passing through the zone during the lifetime of an emergency.
Delay in message broadcasting Maximum delivery ratio of alert messages
Less traffic load
Less delay w.r.t message reception rate
No NS-2.29
Devdhara et al. [27,28] Inter-Vehicle Collision (IVC) scheme All vehicles in the cluster broadcast secure the message to give further information to the other vehicles.
A traffic accident which lies in the same cluster is detected and information about the accident is sent to the other vehicles in the cluster.
Simple Flooding Cluster size
Driver reaction time
Transmission range
No SUMO
OMNET++
VEINS
Clustering Algorithm Techniques
Bhumkar et al. [29] Driver fatigue detection scheme The proposed scheme used real time sensors to detect the driver’s fatigue immediately.
Upon detection, it warns through a notification message and then turns the ignition off.
The scheme performs very well on human behavior like drinking alcohol.
Human behavior causes traffic accidents Driver reaction time
Transmission range
No ARM7
MQ-3 gas sensor
GPS Smart Receiver
Google Map API
Visual Basic (VB)
Nzouonta et al. [30] Road Based Vehicular Traffic (RBVT) routing scheme The proposed routing scheme used the geographical forwarding scheme in order to transmit interest packets between road intersections on the route.
The proposed scheme performs very well on the intersections.
AODV protocol is used to discover the route.
Possibilities use the presented intersection.
The collision probability is used to evaluate the communication in VANETs.
Average packet delivery ratio
High Average delay due to its traffic overhead.
No NS-2.30
SUMO
DCF standard with IEEE 802.11p
Manoj et al. [31] Traffic congestion detection and avoidance scheme After the detection of traffic congestion, the drivers of the vehicles provide magnitude and location of the vehicle.
The affected vehicle, which is involved in the traffic accident, broadcasts the warning message to the RSU.
The RSU further rebroadcasts the warning message to make a decision on an alternate route.
Distribution of the capacity of the bandwidth.
Detection of the Traffic Congestion.
Efficient bandwidth utilization
Minimum message overhead
No Net Beans IDE 7.0
Java
Khatri et al. [32] Traffic congestion detection and avoidance scheme The best forwarder vehicle collects the congestion message.
It checks if the area is congested or not. If not, then the vehicle stores this message in its own memory. Otherwise, it simply shares the congestion location with the other vehicles [33].
Distribution of the capacity of the bandwidth.
Detection of the Traffic Congestion.
Less transmission overhead
Efficient utilization of the bandwidth
No NS-2.0
SUMO