Table 1.
Study method | Number of catchments (treatment/control) | Study period (years before/after DNM) | Parameters studieda | Reference | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Field | 1/1 | 2/2 | TOC | Åström et al. (2001a) |
2 | Field | 1/1 | 2/2 | Runoff, SS, TOC | Åström et al. (2001b) |
3 | Field | 1/1 | 2/2 | N, P | Åström et al. (2002) |
4 | Field | 1/1 | 2/2 | N, P | Åström et al. (2004) |
5 | Modeling | 1/0 | 0/2 | SS | Haahti et al. (2016) |
6 | Field | 2/2 | 2–3/2 | SS, N, P | Hansen et al. (2013) |
7 | Field/Modeling | 6/0 | 1–3/2–4 | N | Hynninen et al. (2011) |
8 | Field | 40/0 | 1–2/> 20 | SS | Joensuu (2013) |
9 | Field | 37/31 | 1–2/1–3 | SS | Joensuu et al. (1999) |
10 | Field | 23/0 | 1–2/6 | SS, DOC, N, P | Joensuu et al. (2001) |
11 | Field | 40/0 | 1–2/2–3 | SS, DOC, N, P | Joensuu et al. (2002) |
12 | Field | 40/0 | 1–2/> 10 | SS, DOC, N, P | Joensuu et al. (2006) |
13 | Modeling | 2/2 | 6/6 | Runoff | Koivusalo et al. (2008) |
14 | Modeling | 1/0 | 0/2 | Runoff, SS | Lappalainen et al. (2010) |
17 | Field | 1/1 | 4/3 | Runoff, SS, N, P | Manninen (1995) |
18 | Field | 1/1 | 4/3 | Runoff, SS, N, P | Manninen (1998) |
19 | Field | 1/0 | 0/3 | Runoff, SS | Marttila and Kløve (2010a) |
20 | Field | 1/0 | 0/3 | Runoff, SS, N, P | Marttila and Kløve (2010b) |
21 | Field/Modeling | 9/8 | 1–3/2–4 | SS, N, P | Nieminen et al. (2010) |
22 | Field | 2/1 | 4–5/2 | Runoff, SS | Stenberg et al. (2015) |
23 | Field | 2/2 | 0.15/2 | Runoff, SS | Tuukkanen et al. (2016) |
aParameters reported in the publications other than runoff, SS, TOC/DOC, N, and P are not mentioned here. N and P may involve their different species, such as total (unfiltered) and dissolved forms, as well as organic and inorganic species