Table 1.
Overview of discourse groups
| Authors | Year | Institutional affiliations during authorship | Type of publication | Cited Foresight report? | Author(s) linked to Foresight? | Number of times ‘trapped’ cited | Article keywords | ‘Word cloud’ keywords |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Discourse A: Reproducing the Foresight narrative | ||||||||
| Black, R. Bennett, S.R.G. Thomas, S.M. Beddington, J.R. |
2011 | UK university and UK Government | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | Yes, directly (all either members of Foresight or the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 5 Abstract = NA Title = 0 |
NA | migration, environmental, change, drivers, people, global, high, low, economic, migrate |
| Adger, W.N. Arnell, N.W. Black, R. Dercon, S. Geddes, A. Thomas, D.S.G |
2015 | UK universities | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | Yes, directly (all members of the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 6 Abstract = 2 Title = 0 |
migration, environmental change, adaptation, governance | risk, climate, economic, social, global, populations, policy, conflict, areas, growth, international |
| Adger, N. Adams, H. |
2013 | UK university | Book chapter | Yes—not in relation to being trapped | Yes (one member of the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 1 Abstract = 0 Title = 0 |
NA | environmental, migration, risk(s), change, mobility, vulnerability, resources, economic, people |
| Black, R. Arnell, N.W. Adger, W.N. Thomas, D. Geddes, A. |
2013 | UK universities | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | Yes, directly (all members of the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 13 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
environmental change, migration, extremes, mobility, displacement | displacement, extreme, events, change, disasters, policy, vulnerability, change, economic, international, global |
| Penning-Rowsell, E.C. Sultana, P. Thompson, P.M. |
2013 | UK university | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | Yes, indirectly (case study authors) | Whole = 6 Abstract = 0 Title = 0 |
hazards, Bangladesh, impacts, evacuation, migration, focus groups | people, work, evacuation, migration, land, areas, hazards, affected, coastal, population |
| Afifi, T. Milan, A. Etzold, B. Schraven, B. Rademacher-Schulz, C. Sakdapolrak, P. Reiff, A. van der Geest, K. Warner, K. |
2015 | Consortium of German research organisations, primarily UNU-EHS | Peer reviewed journal | Yes—not in relation to being trapped | No | Whole = 4 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
human mobility, rainfall variability, food security, climatic stressors | migration, households, rainfall, research, food, variability, adaptation, human, livelihoods, migrants, insecurity, case, study |
| Gray, C. Wise, E. |
2016 | US university | Peer reviewed journal | No | No | Whole = 2 Abstract = 0 Title = 0 |
NA | climate, migration, effects, migrants, data, specification, households, results |
| Milan, A. Ruano, S. |
2014 | UNU-EHS and Guatemalan Ministry | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | No | Whole = 5 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
climate variability, migration, Guatemala, food security, mountain | food, migration, households, research, climate, change, production, variability, local, data, patterns, survey |
| Warner, K. Afifi, T. |
2014 | UNU-EHS | Peer reviewed journal | Yes - not in relation to being trapped | No | Whole = 9 Abstract = 0 Title = 0 |
adaptation, climate change, vulnerability, migration | migration, hh(s) (abbreviation of household(s)), rainfall, food, research, livelihood(s), variability, security |
| Discourse B: Expanding the Foresight report | ||||||||
| Geddes, A. Adger, W.N. Arnell, N.W. Black, R. Thomas, D.S.G. |
2012 | UK universities | Peer reviewed journal | Yes - not in relation to being trapped | Yes, directly (all members of the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 12 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
international migration, internal migration, environmental change, governance, security, displacement, protection | migration, environmental, change, governance, states, international, people, move, displacement, economic |
| Geddes, A. | 2015 | UK university | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | Yes, directly (member of the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 11 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
migration, climate change, security South Mediterranean | migration, environmental, change, effects, people, governance, climate, security |
| Humble, A.T. | 2014 | Earth League, Sweden | Journal article | No | No | Whole = 8 Abstract = 1 Title = 1 |
NA | border(s), migrants, trapped, security, access, countries, migration, dangerous, protection, populations, areas, forced, safer |
| Sow, P. Marmer, E. Scheffran, J. |
2015 | German universities | Peer reviewed journal | Yes - not in relation to being trapped | No | Whole = 1 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
West African migration, climate change, Morocco, racism | migrant(s), migration, climate, country(ies), development, change, social, destination, origin, immigrants |
| Black, R. Collyer, M. |
2014 (book) | UK universities | Book chapter | Yes | Yes (one member of the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 68 Abstract = na Title = 1 |
NA | trapped, populations, move, migration, may, policy, need, research, individuals, immobility, ability, crisis, movement, humanitarian * |
| Black, R. Collyer, M. |
2014 (FMR) | UK universities | Journal article | Yes | Yes (one member of the Lead Expert Group) | Whole = 22 Abstract = 1 Title = 1 |
NA | trapped, move, mobility, migration, populations, policy(ies), crisis, access, resources, ability, unable, movement |
| Bhatta, G.D. Aggarwal, P.K. Poudel, S. Belgrave, D.A. |
2015 | Global research partnership (CGIAR) members (Canada and India) and Canadian city. | Peer reviewed journal | No | No | Whole = 7 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
distress migration, climatic risks, extreme events, rainfall variability, gender dimensions, South Asia | migration, household(s), women, events, adverse, farmers, income, climate(ic), development, community |
| Adams, H. | 2016 | UK university | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | No | Whole = 22 Abstract = 3 Title = 0 |
immobility, trapped, place attachment, behavioural theory, environmental change, migration, Peru | migration, change, place, mobility, environmental, population(s), location, people, climate, attachment, dissatisfaction, negative, trapped |
| Hillman, F. Ziegelmayer, U. |
2016 | German research institutes | Peer reviewed journal | Yes - not in relation to being trapped | No | Whole = 6 Abstract = 1 Title = 0 |
migration, environmental change, climate change, migration trajectories, Ghana, Indonesia | migration, environmental, change, population, trajectories, migrant(s), out-migration |
| Discourse C: Opposing the Foresight report | ||||||||
| Baldwin, A. | 2016 | UK university | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | No | Whole = 1 Abstract = 0 Title = 0 |
climate change, migration, race, neoliberalism, affect | migration, climate, change, affect(ive), white, racial, discourse, future, race, neoliberalism, state, biopower |
| Baldwin, A. Gemenne, F. |
2013 | UK and French universities | Book chapter | Yes - not in relation to being trapped | No | Whole = 2 Abstract = 0 Title = 0 |
NA | migration, climate, change, research, empirical, change-induced, social, policy, political, environmental, refugees |
| Felli, R. Castree, N. |
2012 | UK university | Peer reviewed journal | Yes | No | Whole = 2 Abstract = 0 Title = 0 |
NA | environmental, migration, report, social, adaptation, change, global, neoliberal, state, individual, policy |
NA no article keywords were specified for a particular publication
* A situation where full digital text was not available for use in the creation of a ‘word cloud’. In such an instance, a ‘word cloud’ was created from the excerpts taken from the article due to their relation to Trapped Populations