Table 1.
Background Checks | Bans on the Sale of Assault Weapons and High-Capacity Magazines | Stand-Your-Ground Laws | Prohibitions Associated with Mental Illness | Lost or Stolen Firearm Reporting Requirements | Licensing and Permitting Requirements | Firearm Sales Reporting and Recording Requirements | Child-Access Prevention Laws | Surrender of Firearms by Prohibited Possessors | Minimum Age Requirements | Concealed-Carry Laws | Waiting Periods | Gun-Free Zones | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Purchasing | Possessing | Shall Issue | Permitless Carry | ||||||||||||
Suicide | |||||||||||||||
Total suicides | ↑ L | I | ↑ L | I | ↑ L | I | I | I | |||||||
Firearm suicides | ↑ M | I | ↑ L | I | ↑ M | I | I | ||||||||
Firearm suicides among children | ⊠ L | ||||||||||||||
Firearm self-injuries (nonfatal) | I | ||||||||||||||
Firearm self-injuries (including suicides) | ↑ S | ||||||||||||||
Violent crime | ↑ L | ↑ M | I | I | L | I | |||||||||
Total homicides | ↑ L | I | ↓ M | ↑ L | I | I | I | I | |||||||
Firearm homicides | ↑ M, I* | I | ↓ L | I | I | I | I | I | I | ||||||
Intimate partner homicides | I | I | |||||||||||||
Robberies | I | ||||||||||||||
Assaults | I | ||||||||||||||
Rapes | I | ||||||||||||||
Other violent crime | I | ||||||||||||||
Unintentional injuries and deaths | |||||||||||||||
Unintentional firearm deaths | I | ||||||||||||||
Unintentional firearm injuries and deaths among adults | ↑ L | ||||||||||||||
Unintentional firearm injuries and deaths among children | ↑ S | ||||||||||||||
Unintentional firearm injuries among adults | ↓ L | ||||||||||||||
Unintentional firearm injuries among children | I | ||||||||||||||
Mass shootings | I | I | I | I | I | I | I | I | |||||||
Officer-involved shootings | |||||||||||||||
Defensive gun use | I | ||||||||||||||
Hunting and recreation | |||||||||||||||
Gun industry | |||||||||||||||
Gun ownership | I | ||||||||||||||
Prices of banned firearms in the short term | ↓ L |
NOTE: I = inconclusive; L = limited; M = moderate; S = supportive. When we identified no studies meeting eligibility criteria, cells are blank. ⊠ = the policy increases the outcome; ⊠ = the policy decreases the outcome.
* We concluded that there is moderate evidence that dealer background checks decrease firearm homicides, and there is inconclusive evidence for the effect of private-seller background checks on firearm homicides.