Table 3.
Studies | Country | Study period | Design | Sample size | M/F | Mean age(years) | Co-injuries | PECsq | Mortality | SMRr |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Krause 1997 [ 37 ] | United States | 1985-1996 | Prospective cohort | 141 | 4.3/1a | 24.5±10.9 a | NAb | NAb | 13.5% | NAb |
Levy 1998 [ 19 ] | Zimbabwe | 1988_1994 | Retrospective case-series | 67 | 7.4/1 | NAb | NAb | NAb | 19.4% | NAb |
Yeo 1998 [ 6 ] | Australia | 1955-1994 | Retrospective cohort | 650 | 4.5/1 a | NAb | NAb | NAb | 17.4% | 1.9(1.5-2.3) |
O’Connor2005 [5] | Australia | 1986-1997 | Cohort study | 1355 | 4.01/1 | NAb |
||||
Lidal 2007[ 9 ] | Norway | 1961-1982 | Retrospective | 205 | 3.54:1 | 25.3 | 37% | Men:1.3women:3.3 | ||
Leal-Filho 2008 [38] | Brazil | 1995_2002 | Prospective cohort | 189 | 6.3/1 a | NAb | NAb | NAb | 0 | NAb |
Furlan 2009 [23] | Canada | 1996-2007 | Retrospective cohort | 87 | 2.7/1 a | 52.1 a | NAb | Mean CCIs, Mean CIRSt, Mean number of ICD-9o codes | 2.3% | NAb |
Divanoglou 2010 [30] | Sweden Greece | 2006_2007 | Prospective Population-Based Study | 48 | NAb | NAb | Extraspinal Injuries (Skull, Thorax, Pelvis) | CVDe, Spinal stenosis, ASh, Degenerative | 6.3% | NAb |
Furlan 2010 [25] | Canada | NA | Prospective cohort | 136 | 5.3/1 a | NA | GCSm | NAb | 4.4% | NAb |
Hagen 2010 [20] | Norway | 1952_2001 | Retrospective cohort | 188 | 4.7/1 a | 35.2 | NAb | NAb | 31.4% | 1.94 (1.51, 2.51) |
Ning 2011 [39] | China | 2004-2008 | Retrospective | 248 | 5.6/1 | 46 | 0 | |||
Varma 2010 [10] | United States | 1993-2003 | Retrospective cohort | 715 | 3/1 a | Median age:41a | TBIg,ISSl | NAb | 10.3% | NAb |
Ahoniemi 2011 [1] | Finland | 1976-2007 | Retrospective | 811 | 3.77:1 | Male:34.5 female:33.2 | 4.06% | 2.97 | ||
Krause 2011 [27] | United States | 1998-2008 | Prospective cohort | 402 | 2.9:1 a | 31.1±13.5a | NAb | NAb | 20.9% | NAb |
Krause 2011 [28] | United States | 1995-2006 | Retrospective cohort | 3990 | 3.9:1 a | NAb | NAb | NAb | 10% | NAb |
Kawu 2011 [32] | Nigeria | 1997-2007 | Retrospective cohort | 94 | 4.6/1 a | 37.2±14.2 a | GCSm | NAb | 34% | NAb |
Grossman 2012 [40] | United states | 2005-2010 | Prospective cohort | 56 | 3.7:1 a | 44.6±17.1 a | GCSm,AISp | HTj, Diabetes mellitus, hepatitis C | 0 | NAb |
Middleton 2012 [41] | Australia | 1955 -2006 | Retrospective cohort | 938 | 4.5:1 a | 34±17.4 a | NAb | NAb | 21.3% | 1.7 |
Cao 2013 [42] | United States | 1995-2006 | Cohort | 4042 | 3.88:1 a | NAb | ||||
Nwankwo 2013 [26] | Nigeria | 2009-2012 | Retrospective case-series | 40 | 4.3:1 a | 34.8±3.3 a | Chest lesion/long bone fx/ head injury/ abdomen lesion | NAb | 7.5% | NAb |
Sabre 2013 [24] | Estonia | 1997 -2011 | Retrospective cohort | 205 | NAb | Head injury, ATId | NAb | 21.5% | NAb | |
Löfvenmark 2014 [43] | Botswana | 2011 2013 | Descriptive cross-sectional | 20 | 2.5:1 a | 80% ⩽45 years a | fractures in upper and lower extremities, as well as ribs,abdominal injuries and head trauma. | HIVhypertension | 27.2% | NAb |
Barman 2014 [29] | India | 1981 -2011 | Retrospective cohort | 367 | 8.6:1 a | Median age:31 a | NAb | NAb | 25.3% | NAb |
Hossain2015 [44] | Bangladesh | 2011-2014 | Mixed retrospective-prospective cohort | 201 | 8,51:1 a | 34 (25–44) a | NAb | NAb | 12.43% | NAb |
The data for all patients with cervical and thoracolumbar spinal cord injury;
NA: not available;
CHI: closed head injury;
ATI: associated traumatic injury;
CVD: cardiovascular disease;
PD: pulmonary disease;
TBI: traumatic brain injury;
AS: ankylosing spondylitis;
OPLL: ossification of posterior longitudinal ligament;
HT: hypertension;
OA: osteoarthritis;
ISS: Injury Severity Score;
GCS: Glasgow Coma Scale;
GI disease: gastrointestinal disease;
ICD-9 codes: international classification of disease-ninth revision;
AIS: Abbreviated Injury Scale;
PECs: Preexisting co-morbidity;
SMR: standardized mortality ratio;
CCI: Charlson Comorbidity Index;
CIRS: Cumulative Index Rating Scale;
AS: Ankylosing Spondylitis.