Skip to main content
. 2018 Aug 10;13(8):e0200204. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0200204

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

Reference Study period Country Tumor type Data Sources Sample size Stage Method Analysis Outcome data NOS
Wu et al[17] 1999–2008 China DA Institutional 141 I-IV CR UV OS indirect 9
Schwameis et al[18] 1994–2012 Austria SBA Institutional 26 NR CR UV OS indirect 6
Guo et al[19] 2000–2011 China SBA Institutional 149 NR CR UV OS indirect 8
Young et al[20] 1992–2010 United States SBA National 1644 I-IV CR MU OS direct 9
Kanhan et al[21] 1996–2011 Britain SBA Institutional 48 ES CR UV OS/RFS direct 8
Ecker et al[22] 1998–2011 United States SBA National 2297 I-IV CR UV OS direct 8
Legue et al[23] 1999–2013 Netherlands SBA National 1194 I-IV CR MU OS direct 8
Fu et al[24] 1997–2009 United States DA Institutional 64 III CRT MU OS/DFS direct 7
Aydin et al[25] 2003–2013 Turkey SBA Institutional 78 I-IV CR UV OS/DFS direct 9
Kim et al[26] 1991–2002 Korea DA Institutional 24 I-IV CRT UV OS/RFS indirect 8
Koo et al[27] 1989–2009 Korea SBA Institutional 52 I-IV CR MU OS/DFS direct 7
Overman et al[28] 1990–2006 United States SBA Institutional 54 I-IV CRT MU OS/DFS direct 8
Poultsides et al[29] 1984–2006 United States DA Institutional 122 I-IV CRT MU OS direct 9
Zaanan et al[30] 1996–2008 France SBA Institutional 93 NR CR UV OS/RFS direct 9
Ecker et al[31] 1998–2011 United States DA National 256 NR CR UV OS direct 9

SBA: small bowel adenocarcinoma; DA: duodenal adenocarcinoma; NR: not reported; ES: Early stage; CR: Chemotherapy; CRT: Chemoradiation; UV: univariate; MU: multivariate; OS: overall survival; RFS: recurrence-free survival; DFS: disease-free survival; NOS: Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. NOS: Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.