Table 2.
Author | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | No | Score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alentorn-Geli 201553 | No | No | Yes | U | No | No | U | No | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | 2 |
Beynnon 200660 | No | No | Yes | No | No | No | Yes | U | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 3 |
Beynnon 2014a35 | No | U | U | No | U | U | Yes | Yes | U | U | No | U | U | Yes | 3 |
Beynnon 2014b42 | No | No | Yes | U | No | U | U | Yes | U | U | Yes | Yes | U | No | 4 |
Beynnon 2014c24 | No | No | U | No | No | No | U | Yes | No | U | No | U | NA | U | 1 |
Bisson 201034 | No | U | U | No | U | U | Yes | Yes | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | 3 |
Chaudhari 200948 | No | U | Yes | U | U | U | U | Yes | U | NA | No | NA | NA | Yes | 3 |
Dare 201541 | No | U | U | Yes | U | U | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | No | Yes | 3 |
Everhart 201029 | No | No | Yes | No | U | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | U | No | U | NA | U | 4 |
Fernández-Jaén 201528 | No | No | Yes | U | No | No | U | No | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 2 |
Flynn 200571 | No | No | U | U | No | No | No | No | No | U | No | U | NA | No | 0 |
Hägglund 201659 | Yes | U | U | U | U | U | No | Yes | No | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 3 |
Hewett 200555 | Yes | U | Yes | U | U | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | U | Yes | 3 |
Khayambashi 201651 | Yes | U | No | U | U | U | Yes | Yes | U | U | Yes | Yes | U | No | 5 |
Khoschnau 200863 | No | No | U | U | U | No | U | No | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 1 |
Kramer 200745 | Yes | No | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | No | No | NA | NA | Yes | NA | Yes | 6 |
LaPrade 199426 | Yes | U | U | No | U | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | U | Yes | 2 |
Lefevre 201361 | No | U | No | U | U | U | U | U | No | U | No | U | U | No | 0 |
Lund-Hanssen 199431 | No | U | U | U | U | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 1 |
Mannion 201469 | No | U | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | No | U | No | U | U | Yes | 2 |
Myer 200952 | Yes | U | Yes | No | U | U | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | U | 3 |
Myer 201557 | Yes | U | No | U | U | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | NA | U | 1 |
Nilstad 201469 | Yes | No | No | U | U | U | No | Yes | No | U | No | U | NA | No | 2 |
O'Connell 201567 | No | U | U | U | U | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | U | Yes | 1 |
Orchard 199919 | U | No | U | U | U | U | U | No | No | U | No | U | NA | U | 0 |
Orchard 200520 | No | No | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | No | U | No | U | NA | U | 1 |
Parkkari 200823 | Yes | U | NA | NA | U | U | Yes | No | No | Yes | No | U | NA | U | 3 |
Pope 200222 | Yes | U | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | NA | No | U | U | Yes | 2 |
Posthumus 2009a65 | No | U | No | No | U | U | U | No | No | NA | No | NA | NA | Yes | 1 |
Posthumus 201066 | No | No | Yes | No | No | No | No | No | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 2 |
Posthumus 2009b64 | No | No | Yes | U | No | No | No | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | U | 2 |
Posthumus 201268 | No | No | Yes | No | No | No | No | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 3 |
Quatman 201156 | Yes | U | U | U | No | No | U | No | U | NA | No | NA | NA | Yes | 2 |
Raschner 201249 | No | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | U | U | No | U | NA | U | 0 |
Ruedl 200962 | No | U | Yes | U | U | U | No | Yes | U | U | No | U | U | No | 2 |
Ruedl 201121 | No | No | No | U | U | U | U | No | No | U | No | U | U | Yes | 1 |
Ruedl 201272 | No | No | No | No | No | No | U | Yes | No | NA | NA | NA | NA | Yes | 2 |
Saper 201644 | No | U | U | No | U | U | U | Yes | No | U | No | NA | NA | Yes | 2 |
Shaw 201533 | No | U | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 2 |
Simon 201032 | No | U | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | U | NA | No | NA | NA | Yes | 2 |
Souryal 199325 | Yes | No | U | NA | U | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | U | No | Yes | Yes | No | 6 |
Stijak 201446 | No | No | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 2 |
Sturnick 2014a36 | U | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | Yes | U | NA | No | NA | NA | U | 2 |
Sturnick 2014b37 | Yes | U | U | U | U | U | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 3 |
Sturnick 201530 | No | U | U | U | No | No | U | No | U | U | No | U | U | Yes | 1 |
Tainaka 201458 | No | No | Yes | U | Yes | U | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | U | 3 |
Terauchi 201139 | No | No | U | U | No | No | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 2 |
Todd 201040 | No | No | U | NA | U | No | Yes | Yes | No | U | NA | Yes | NA | U | 3 |
Uhorchak 200312 | Yes | No | U | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | U | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | 8 |
Vyas 201143 | No | No | No | U | U | U | U | No | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 1 |
Whitney 201447 | No | No | U | No | No | No | U | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | U | 1 |
Xiao 201627 | No | U | Yes | U | U | U | Yes | No | No | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 3 |
Zazulak 200750 | Yes | No | Yes | U | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | U | No | U | Yes | U | 6 |
Zebis 200954 | Yes | No | U | No | U | U | Yes | No | U | U | No | U | No | Yes | 3 |
Zeng 201438 | No | U | Yes | U | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | U | U | No | U | NA | Yes | 6 |
Column Abbreviations: A = Prospective study; B = Concealed/blind group assignment; C = Group similarities at baseline; D = participant blinding; E = data collector blinding; F = outcome assessor blinding; G = previous knee injuries excluded; H = results specified for non-contact; I = no influence of other risk factors; J = acceptable compliance; K = dropout reasons reported; L = acceptable dropout rate; M = duration of intervention comparable; N = intention to treat analysis. Yes = criteria was explained and acceptable (1 point); No = criteria missing or not acceptable (0 points); U = Unknown, criteria not explained or unclear; NA = not applicable (0 points).