Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 7;12(9):2187–2197. doi: 10.1038/s41396-018-0181-2

Table 3.

Results from mixed models evaluating the statistical significance of effects of trenching and layer on relative abundances of functional guilds of fungi, fungal biomass, 15N relative abundance and activities of selected extracellular enzymes in organic soil profiles of a boreal forest 1 year (fungal guilds, biomass and δ15N) and 4 years (all variables except δ15N) after disruption of root connections by trenching

Variable trenching layer trenching x layer
F df P F df P F df P
Fungal biomass (µg ergosterol gOM−1):
 1 year after trenching 0.001,38 0.97 8.85,57 <0.0001 1.85,57 0.14
 4 years after trenching 11.41,16 0.004 (−) 4.85,54 0.001 3.05,54 0.02
Fungal guilds (% of ITS markers), 1 year after trenching:
 Ectomycorrhizal fungi 14.31,22 0.001 (−) 9.05,58 <0.0001 1.45,58 0.23
 Root basidiomycetes 1.81,23 0.19 7.45,57 <0.0001 1.25,57 0.33
 Root ascomycetes 3.71,24 0.07 18.95,59 <0.0001 2.95,59 0.02
 Litter Agaricomycetes 0.31,13 0.63 16.95,53 <0.0001 0.25,53 0.98
 Litter ascomycetes 7.21,27 0.01 (+) 113.85,52 <0.0001 0.65,52 0.74
 Yeasts and moulds 5.31,27 0.03 (+) 43.25,57 <0.0001 1.55,57 0.20
Fungal guilds (% of ITS markers), 4 years after trenching:
 Ectomycorrhizal fungi 147.81,31 <0.0001 (−) 29.95,60 <0.0001 8.45,60 <0.0001
 Root basidiomycetes 3.81,24 0.06 6.55,55 <0.0001 1.25,55 0.34
 Root ascomycetes 0.01,23 0.95 61.15,59 <0.0001 1.15,59 0.36
 Litter Agaricomycetes 0.91,18 0.37 43.15,54 <0.0001 0.75,54 0.66
 Litter ascomycetes 0.31,33 0.60 115.65,48 <0.0001 1.25,48 0.31
 Yeasts and moulds 6.81,22 0.02 (+) 38.25,58 <0.0001 0.95,58 0.46
Enzyme activities (nmol gOM−1 s−1), 4 years after trenching:
 Total peroxidase 59.31,30 <0.0001 (− ) 8.94,56 <0.0001 6.34,56 0.0003
 Mn peroxidase 20.91,31 <0.0001 ( −) 1.55,64 0.22 4.15,64 0.003
 Laccase 0.11,27 0.82 47.35,65 <0.0001 1.55,65 0.20
 BG 3.31,24 0.08 8.35,65 <0.0001 0.45,65 0.82
 CBH 6.31,23 0.02 (−) 13.15,63 <0.0001 1.05,63 0.43
 NAG 10.41,24 0.004 (−) 10.75,67 <0.0001 1.55,67 0.19
 CiBH 6.81,25 0.02 (− ) 4.45,66 0.002 0.75,56 0.64
δ15N, 1 year after trenching:
0.31,20 0.59 179.65,68 <0.0001 1.85,68 0.13

Significant values (P < 0.05) are presented in bold and the direction of response is indicated in parenthesis. Degrees of freedom (df) for F values are given as subscripts (effect, error) after each F value