Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Aug 16.
Published in final edited form as: Econ Educ Rev. 2018 May 4;65:107–125. doi: 10.1016/j.econedurev.2018.05.001

Table 1:

Description of experimental design

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Grantee and sample size Site Treatment Curriculum Control Curriculum (a) Whole school randomized to same Treatment? Some within-school randomization to treatment? Children randomized across treatment conditions within school? Total number of schools (clusters) Number of schools, classrooms, students, if school randomization
(T/C)
Number of classrooms and students, if within-school randomization
(T/C)
I. Literacy vs. HighScope and Creative Curriculum
 University of North Florida
 School n= 27;
 Classroom n= 27;
 Child n=210
FL Early Literacy and Learning Model Creative Curriculum Y (same elementary school shared same treatment status) N N 72 14, 14, 120

13, 13, 90

 Florida State University
 School n=11;
 Classroom n=19;
 Child n=200
FL Literacy Express HighScope Y N N 5, 10, 100

6, 9, 100

 Florida State University
 School n=12;
 Classroom n=20;
 Child n=200
FL DLM Early Childhood Express supplemented with Open Court Reading Pre-K HighScope Y N N 6, 11, 100

6, 9, 100

 University of California-Berkeley
 School n= 17;
 Classroom n=39;
 Child n=260
NJ Ready Set Leap HighScope N Y N 21, 120

18, 140

 University of Virginia
 School n=5;
 Classroom n=14;
 Child n=200
VA Language Focused HighScope N Y N 7, 100

7, 100

II. Literacy vs. Locally-Developed Curriculum
 University of Texas
 Health Science Center at Houston
 School n=12;
 Classroom n=28;
 Child n=190
TX Doors to Discovery Locally Developed Y N N 41 8, 14, 100

4, 14, 90

 University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston
 School n=10;
 Classroom n=30;
 Child n=200
TX Let’s Begin with the Letter People Locally Developed Y N N 7, 15, 100

4, 15, 90

 Vanderbilt University
 School n=13;
 Classroom n=14;
 Child n=200
TN Bright Beginnings Locally Developed Y N N 7, 7, 100

6, 7, 100

III. Math vs. HighScope and Creative Curriculum
 University of California-Berkeley and SUNY University of Buffalo
 School n=36;
 Classroom n=40;
 Child n=300
CA and NY Pre-K Mathematics supplemented with DLM Early Childhood Express (Math Software only) Creative Curriculum or HighScope N Y (but in separate buildings) N 36 19, 20, 150

17, 20, 150

IV. Creative Curriculum vs. Locally-Developed Curriculum
 University of North Carolina at Charlotte
 School n=5;
 Classroom n=18;
 Child n=170
NC and GA Creative Curriculum Locally Developed N Y Y 17 9, 90

9, 80

 Vanderbilt University
 School n=12;
 Classroom n=14;
 Child n=210
TN Creative Curriculum Locally Developed Y N N 6, 7, 90

6, 7, 100

Note: Ns are rounded to the nearest 10 in accordance with NCES data policies.