Table 4.
Factor | Result | Evidence | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
Disease related factors | |||
No factors were studied | |||
Body functions and structures | |||
No factors were studied | |||
Activities | |||
No factors were studied | |||
(Work) participation | |||
Previous episode(s) of sickness absence | 2+ | ||
Sado et al. [91] | Positive | Time to recurrent SA | |
Koopmans et al. [88] | Positive | Recurrence of SA | |
Environmental factors | |||
Medication use | Insufficient | ||
Arends et al. [90] | No effect | Recurrent SA at 12 months | |
Environmental work related factors | |||
Industry/sector | Insufficient | ||
Koopmans et al. [88] | Positive | Recurrence of SA | |
Company size > 100 | Insufficient | ||
Arends et al. [90] | Positive | Recurrent SA at 12 months | |
Supervisor support | Insufficient | ||
Arends et al. [90] | No effect | Recurrent SA at 12 months | |
Coworker support | Insufficient | ||
Arends et al. [90] | No effect | Recurrent SA at 12 months | |
Conflict with supervisor | Insufficient | ||
Arends et al. [90] | Positive | Recurrent SA at 12 months | |
Job demands | Insufficient | ||
Endo et al. [92] | Positive | Recurrent SA | |
Job control | Insufficient | ||
Endo et al. [92] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Type of social security contributions (general scheme vs self-employed) | Insufficient | ||
Real et al. [64] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Personal factors | |||
Older age | 1+, 3−, 4ne | ||
Koopmans et al. [86] | Negative ♀ No effect ♂ |
Recurrence of SA | |
Koopmans et al. [88] | Negative | Recurrence of SA | |
Roelen et al. [87] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Sado et al. [91] | Negative | Time to recurrent SA | |
Endo et al. [92] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Real et al. [64] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Norder et al. [93] | Positive | Recurrent SA episode | |
Gender | 7ne | ||
Sado et al. [91] | No effect | Time to recurrent SA | |
Koopmans et al. [86] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Koopmans et al. [88] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Roelen et al. [87] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Norder et al. [93] | No effect | Recurrent SA episode | |
Endo et al. [92] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Real et al. [64] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Low socio-economic position | 1+, 1ne | ||
Roelen et al. [87] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Virtanen et al. [75] | Positive | Recurrence of SA ≥ 90 days | |
Marital status unmarried | 1+, 3ne | ||
Koopmans et al. [88] | Positive ♀ No effect ♂ |
Recurrence of SA | |
Roelen et al. [87] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Norder et al. [93] | No effect | Recurrent SA episode | |
Cohabiting | 2ne | ||
Arends et al. [90] | No effect | Recurrent SA at 12 months | |
Living alone | |||
Endo et al. [92] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Co-morbid conditions | 2+, 1− | ||
Ervasti et al. [89] | Positive | Recurrence of SA | |
Koopmans et al. [88] | Positive | Recurrence of SA | |
Arends et al. [90] | Negative | Recurrent SA at 12 months | |
Personal work related factors | |||
Higher salary scale | 1−, 1ne | ||
Koopmans et al. [88] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Roelen et al. [87] | Negative | Recurrence of SA | |
Full-time vs part-time employed | 3ne | ||
Koopmans et al. [88] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Roelen et al. [87] | No effect | Recurrence of SA | |
Norder et al. [93] | No effect | Recurrent SA episode | |
Being a shift worker (versus day worker) | Insufficient | ||
Norder et al. [62] | No effect | Recurrent SA episode | |
Working as a manager | Insufficient | ||
Endo et al. [92] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Shorter duration of employment (tenure) | 2−, 1ne | ||
Koopmans et al. [88] | Negative ♀ No effect ♂ |
Recurrence of SA | |
Roelen et al. [87] | Negative | Recurrence of SA | |
Time for commute | Insufficient | ||
Endo et al. [92] | No effect | Recurrent SA | |
Job title | Insufficient | ||
Endo et al. [92] | No effect | Recurrent SA |
In Koopmans et al., Roelen et al., and Norder et al. recurrent was defined as SA > 28 days after RTW; in Real et al. recurrence was defined as within 180 days after RTW
+ positive related with recurrent SA, − negative related with recurrent SA, ne not related with recurrent SA