Table 1.
Literature summary of prostate irradiation with intraprostatic directed boost
| Author | N | IDN identification modality | Treatment technique | NCCN | Median PSA (μg/L) | Median follow-up time | Volume delineation and margins | Boost technique | Dose (Gy/fr) | ADT | 5-year bDFS (phoenix) | Survival (DSS, OS) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zelefsky et al28 | 4 | 1,5T ERC MRSI (elevated choline + elevated creatine-to-citrate ratio) | LDR B (I125) |
LR (2) IR (2) HR (0) |
4.5 | NR | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate |
LDR B (I125) | PTVb = 150% of PTVpr PTVpr = 100–145 Gy |
No | NR | NR |
| DiBiase et al29 | 15 | 1,5T ERC MRSI (elevated choline + elevated creatine-to-citrate ratio) | LDR B (I125) |
LR (15) IR (0) HR (0) |
7.1 | NR | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate + 2 mm | LDR B (I125) | PTVb = 188 Gy PTVpr = 145 Gy |
No | NR | NR |
| De Meerleer et al30 | 15 | 1,5T ERC MRI (T2W) + biopsy |
IMRT (3 field, Step and Shoot) |
LR (2) IR (8) HR (5) |
10.2 | NR | PTVb = GTV PTVpr= (prostate + SV)+ 7–10 mm | IMRT | PTVb = 80 Gy/37 PTVpr = 74 Gy/37 |
Yes (73%) neoadj + adj (6–36 mo) |
NR | NR |
| Singh et al31 | 3 | 3T ERC MRI (T2W + DCE + DWI) + biopsy | IMRT | NR | NR | 3–18 | PTVb = GTV + 3 mm PTVpr = prostate + 7 mm |
PTVb = 94,5 Gy/42 PTVpr = 75,6 Gy/42 |
No | NR | NR | |
| Fonteyne et al32 | 230 | 1,5T ERC MRI (T2W + T1W) or MRSI | IMRT (3 field, Step and Shoot) |
LR (17) IR (97) HR (116) |
11.2 | NR | PTVb = GTV + 4 mm PTVpr = (prostate ± SV) + 4 mm |
IMRT | PTVb = 80 Gy/39 PTVpr = 78 Gy/39 |
No | NR | NR |
| Ares et al33 | 77 | ERC MRI (T2W + DCE) +biopsy | 3DCRT + HDR B (Ir192) | LR (6) IR (25) HR (46) |
NR | 41.2 | PTVb = boost prostate volume PTVpr = prostate + VS PLN |
HDR B (Ir192) | PTVb = 85.6-99.2 Gy PTVpr = 64 Gy/32 |
Yes (>80%) neoadj/adj (18–24 mo) |
78.8% | 90% 5-year DSS |
| Miralbell et al34 | 50 | ERC MRI (T2W + DCE) +biopsy | 3DCRT/IMRT (Step and shoot, sliding window and VMAT) | LR (5) IR (12) HR (33) |
NR | NR | PTVb = GTV + 3 mm PTVpr = prostate + SV PLN |
SBRT | PTVb = 80-99 Gy PTVpr = 64 Gy/32 |
Yes (66%) neoadj + adj (6-30 mo) |
98% | 100% 5-year DSS |
| Schick et al35 | 77 | ERC MRI (T2W + DCE) +biopsy | 3DCRT + HDR B (Ir192) | LR (7) IR (9) HR (61) |
NR | 62–67 | PTVb = hemi prostate PTVpr = prostate + vs PLN |
HDR B (Ir192) | PTVb = 88-104 Gy PTVpr = 64.4 Gy/32 |
Yes (81%) neoadj + adj (18–24 mo) |
70.5–79.7% | NR |
| Ellis et al36, 37 | 239 | 111In-Capromab SPECT Imaging | LDR prostate +3DCRT in 37% | LR (116) IR (94) HR (29) |
7.6 | 84 | PTVb = GTV + 5 mm PTVpr = prostate + 2–5 mm ±PLN |
LDR prostate (Pd103 or I125) | PTVb = 150% of PTVpr PTVpr = 108–144 Gy (I125) PTVpr = 100–125 Gy (Pd103) |
Yes (21%) neoadj |
84.6% | 97.7% 10-year DSS 84.8% 10-year OS |
| Wong et al38 | 71 | 111In-Capromab SPECT Imaging | IMRT | LR (31) IR (30) HR (10) |
6.1 | 66 | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate + SV (when involved) + 6 mm |
IMRT | PTVb = 82 Gy (SIB) PTVpr = 75.6 Gy/42 |
Yes (24%) adj (6–12 mo) |
94% | 93% 5-year OS |
| Pinkawa et al39 | 66 | 18F-Fluorocholine PET CT | IMRT | LR (23) IR (21) HR (22) |
14 | 19 | PTVb = GTV + 3-4 mm PTVpr = prostate + SV + 4–8 mm |
IMRT | PTVb = 80 Gy (SIB) PTVpr = 76 Gy/38 |
Yes (16%) (NR) |
NR | NR |
| Ippolito et al40 | 40 | 1,5T ERC MRI + biopsy | IMRT | LR (4) IR (17) HR (19) |
7 | 19 | PTVb= (GTV + 5 mm)+1 cm PTVpr = prostate + SV + 1 cm |
IMRT | PTVb = 80 Gy (SIB) PTVpr = 72 Gy/40 |
Yes (100%) neoadj + adj(24 mo) |
100% | NR |
| Myers et al41 | 26 | TRUS | IMRT+ HDR B (Ir192) |
LR (7) IR(19) HR (0) |
6.1 | 53 | PTVb = peripheral zone PTVpr = (prostate+1.5 cm + VS + 5 mm) + 5 mm PLN |
HDR B (Ir192) | PTVb = 9 Gy + 63 Gy/28 PTVpr = 6Gy + 63 Gy/28 |
Yes (73%) neoadj + adj(4 mo) |
100% | NR |
| Aluwini et al42 | 50 | 1.5 T MRI (T1W + T2W) | SBRT (Cyberknife) | LR (30) IR (20) HR (0) |
8.2 | 23 | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate + 3 mm |
SBRT (Cyberknife) | PTVb = 44 Gy (SIB) PTVpr = 38 Gy/4, daily |
No | 100% 2-year bDFS | NR |
| Schild et al43 | 78 | 1.5 T MRI (T2W + DCE + DWI) | IMRT (sliding window and VMAT) | LR (18) IR (43) HR (17) |
6.7 | 36 | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate + 3 mm |
IMRT (sliding window and VMAT) | PTVb = 81-83 Gy (SIB) PTVpr = 77,4 Gy/43 |
Yes (41%) adj(6–30 mo) |
92% 3-year bDFS | 95% 3-year OS |
| Gomez-Iturriaga et al44 | 15 | 1.5 T MRI (T2W + DCE + DWI) | IMRT + HDR B (Ir192) | LR (0) IR and HR: not specified |
9 | 18 | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate |
HDR B (Ir192) | PTVb = 18.75 Gy + 37.5 Gy/15 PTVpr = 15 Gy + 37.5 Gy/15 |
No | NR | NR |
| King et al45 | 47 | MRSI (elevated choline + elevated creatine-to-citrate ratio) | LDR (I125or Pd103) + IMRT PLN for 1 patient | LR (35) IR (12) HR (0) |
5.1 | 86.4 | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate PLN |
LDR (I125 or Pd103) |
PTVb = 150% of PTVpr PTVpr = 144 Gy (I125) or 140 Gy (Pd103) |
Yes (17%) neoadj |
98% 10-year bDFS | 84% 10-year OS |
| Sundahl et al46 | 225 | 1,5T ERC MRI or 3T MRI (T1W + T2W) | IMRT | LR (5) IR (97) HR (123) |
NR | 72 | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate ± SV + 7 mm |
IMRT | PTV1 = 82 Gy (SIB) PTV2 = 78 Gy/38 |
No | 84% 6-year bDFS | NR |
| Kotecha et al47 | 24 | MRI (no specification) | SBRT (Cyberknife) | LR (0) IR (11) HR (13) |
NR | 25 | PTVb = GTV PTVpr = prostate + SV+3 mm(0 mm posteriorly) |
SBRT (Cyberknife) | PTVb = 50 Gy (SIB) PTVpr = 36.25 Gy/5 |
Yes (67%) Adj(4–30 mo) |
95.8% 2-year bDFS | NR |
| Uzan et al 48 | 11 | MRI (T2W + DCE + DWI) + biopsy | IMRT (VMAT) | NR | 15.9 | 36 | PTVb = GTV + 5 mm PTVpr 1 = prostate + SV + 9 mm PTVpr 2 = prostate and base of SV + 5 mm |
IMRT (VMAT) | PTVb = 85–105 Gy (SIB) PTVpr1 = 64 Gy/37 PTVpr2 = 74 Gy/37 |
Yes (100%) neoadj + adj (6–36 mo) |
NR | NR |
| Garibaldi et al49 | 15 | 1.5 ERC MRI (T2W + DWI + DCE) | IMRT (VMAT) | LR (0) IR (14) HR (1) |
6.5 | 16 | PTVb = GTV + 6 mm PTVpr 1 = prostate + 7 mm (5 mm posteriorly) PTVpr 2 = SV + 5–7 mm |
IMRT (VMAT) | PTVb = 83.2 Gy (SIB) PTVpr1 = 75.2 Gy/32 PTVpr2 = 67.2 Gy/32 |
Yes (80%) neoadj + adj (6–24 mo) |
100% | NR |
3DCRT, 3-D conformational radiation therapy; ADT, androgen deprivation therapy; Adj, adjuvant ADT; bDFS, biochemical disease-free survival; CTCAE v2, Common Terminology Criteria of Adverse Events version 2, CTCAE v4, Common Terminology Criteria of Adverse Events version 4; DCE, dynamic contrast enhancement; DSS, disease-specific survival; EORTC, European Organization for Research and Treatment for Cancer; DWI, diffusion-weighted imaging; EPIC, Expanded Prostate Cancer Index Composite questionnaire; ERC, endorectal coil; Fr, fraction; GI, gastrointestinal; GTV, Gross tumor volume (=dominant intraprostatic lesion); GU, genitourinary; Gy, gray; HDR, high–dose rate brachytherapy; HR, high risk; IDN, intraprostatic dominant nodule; IMRT, intensity-modulated radiation therapy; IR, intermediate risk; LDR B, low–dose rate brachytherapy; LR, low risk; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; mpMRI, multiparametric MRI [T2 weighed + dynamic contrast enhancement (DCE) + diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI)]; MRSI, magnetic resonance spectroscopic imaging; NCCN, National Comprehensive Cancer Network; Neoadj, neoadjuvant ADT; NR, not reported; OS, overall survival; PET CT, positron emission tomography–computed tomography; PLN, pelvic lymph nodes irradiation; PLND, pelvic lymph nodes dissection; PSA, prostate-specific antigen; PTV, planning target volume; PTVb, boost; PTVpr, whole prostate; SBRT, stereotactic body radiation therapy; SPECT, single-photon emission computed tomography; SV, seminal vesicles; TRUS, transrectal ultrasound; VMAT, volumetric modulated arc therapy.