Deductive fallacy |
Denial of the antecedent |
If p then q. Not-p.Therefore not-q. |
If the glass falls down then it breaks. The glass does not fall down. Therefore, the glass does not break. |
If you carry an umbrella then you stay dry. You do not carry an umbrella. Therefore, you do not stay dry. |
If a paper is published in a high impact factor journal, then it is of high quality. This paper is not published in a high impact factor journal. Therefore, this paper is not of high quality. |
Inductive fallacies |
Argument from ignorance |
It is not known that p is true (false). Therefore p is false (true). |
The book is not listed in the library catalog. Therefore, the book is not in the library. |
No one has proven that ghosts do not exist. Therefore, ghosts exist. |
This paper does not have the quality sign of having been published in a high impact factor journal. Therefore, this paper is not of high quality. |
Argument From authority |
This expert says that p is true. Therefore p is true. |
Medical experts say that this treatment is safe. Therefore, this treatment is safe. |
My parents say that Santa Claus exists. Therefore, Santa Claus exists. |
This paper does not have the authority backing of having been published in a high impact factor journal. Therefore, this paper is not of high quality. |
Ad hominem argument |
This untrustworthy person says that p is true. Therefore p is false. |
A person without training says that this treatment is safe. Therefore, this treatment is not safe. |
A person without a driver’s license says “don’t drink alcohol while driving.” Therefore, it is false that you should not drink alcohol while driving. |
This paper was published in a journal with low quality reputation due to a low impact factor. Therefore, this paper is not of high quality. |
|