Skip to main content
. 2018 Aug 30;13(8):e0203315. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0203315

Table 3. Pairwise comparison of perioperative outcomes.

Pairwise meta-analysis (mortality)
Included Studies Comparisons OR (95% CI) I2 P
7 studies NTG vs. DILT 0.83 (0.29, 2.41) 0.00% 1.000
5 studies Placebo vs. NTG 1.59 (0.31, 8.28) 0.00% 0.987
3 studies Placebo vs. DILT 4.00 (0.64, 25.15) 0.00% 0.574
Pairwise meta-analysis (Cardiac protection)
Included Studies Comparisons OR (95% CI) I2 P
post-MI
7 studies NTG vs. DILT 1.83 (0.77, 4.30) 0.00% 0.975
4 studies Placebo vs. NTG 2.24 (0.80, 6.28) 0.00% 0.596
1 studies Placebo vs. DILT 6.20 (0.27, 141.32) - -
TIE
5 studies NTG vs. DILT 1.67(0.99, 2.82) 3.9% 0.384
4 studies Placebo vs. NTG 1.42 (0.73, 2.75) 0.0% 0.707
A-fib
7 studies NTG vs. DILT 2.67 (1.15, 6.24) 62.20% 0.014
2 studies Placebo vs. DILT 3.00 (1.18, 7.63) 0.0% 0.782
Pairwise meta-analysis (Cardiac protection)
Included Studies Comparisons MD (95% CI) I2 P
CK
1 study NTG vs. Placebo -36.00 (-232.18, 160.18) NA NA
5 studies DILT vs. NTG -90.29 (-156.79, -23.79) 0.00% 0.691
CKMB
6 studies DILT vs. NTG -12.47 (-18.33, -6.61) 63.5% 0.018
1 study DILT vs. Placebo -1.30 (-7.29,4.69) NA NA
Trop-T
4 Studies DILT vs. NTG -0.66 (-0.87, -0.44) 0.0% 0.42
Pairwise meta-analysis (Cardiac function)
Included Studies Comparisons OR (95% CI) I2 P
Inotrope
4 studies NTG vs. DILT 1.78 (0.78, 4.07) 26.1% 0.255
2 studies Placebo vs. DILT 0.19 (0.04, 0.73) 0.0% 0.419
Pairwise meta-analysis (Cardiac function)
Included Studies Comparisons MD (95% CI) I2 P
CCI
5 studies DILT vs. NTG -0.02 (-0.18, 0.13) 21.3% 0.279
2 studies NTG vs. Placebo 0.16 (-0.98, 0.42) 69.2% 0.072
1 study DILT vs. Placebo -0.10 (-0.62, 0.42) NA NA
HR
5 studies NTG vs. Placebo 2.54 (-6.22, 11.29) 95.1% 0.00
1 study DILT vs. NTG -13.00 (-23.56, -2.45) NA NA
1 study DILT vs. Placebo -9.40 (-18.88, 0.08) NA NA
mBP (mmHg)
3 studies NTG vs. Placebo -2.61 (-11.70, 6.48) 98.30% 0.00
1 study DILT vs. NTG 2.00 (-7.92, 11.92) NA NA
1 study DILT vs. Placebo 1.90 (-8.54, 12.34) NA NA
mPAP (mmHg)
2 studies NTG vs. Placebo -2.29 (-4.81, 0.23) 29.40% 0.23
1 study DILT vs. NTG -1.00 (-3.04, 1.04) NA NA
PAWP (mmHg)
4 studies NTG vs. Placebo -1.05 (-1.43, -0.70) 0.0% 0.64
1 study DILT vs. NTG -0.50 (-2.97, 1.97) NA NA
1 study DILT vs. Placebo 0.80 (-1.84, 3.44) NA NA

Note: OR greater than 1 favor the first treatment.