Table 2. Summary of conventionally fractionated IMRT or PBT reirradiation studies.
Study | No. patients | Histology | Staging | Median interval to reRT (mo) | Initial RT dose Gy (median) | reRT dose Gy (median) | Local control | Median OS mo (range) | Other therapies | Toxicities |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Centingoz et al. [2009] | 38 | NSCLC | Not described | 9 | 30 | 25 (10×2.5 Gy) | Not described | 3 (NS) | Not described | ≥ acute or late grade 3 toxicity (42%), acute toxicity (39%), late toxicity (12%), grade 5 (17.6%) |
McAvoy et al. [2013] | 33 | NSCLC | I: 7/33; II: 5/33; III: 20/33; IV: 1/33 | 36 | 63 | 60 | 54% locoregional control at 1 year | 11.1 [1–32] | 45% of patients received chemotherapy prior to reRT; 6% underwent surgery; 6% underwent surgery and chemotherapy; eight patients received concurrent chemotherapy with reRT; | ≥ acute grade 3 toxicities, 9% esophageal, 21% pulmonary |
Kruser et al. [2014] | 37 | NSCLC | I: 2/37; II: 5/37; III: 20/37; IV: 10/37 | 11.2 | 57 | 30 | Not described | 5.1 (0.5–42) | Concurrent chemotherapy given in 33% of patients; palliative RT to non-thoracic sites in 16% of patients; 81% of patients had chemotherapy with first course of RT | Grade 2 pulmonary toxicity of 8.1%, grade 3 pulmonary toxicity of 5.4%; grade 2 esophagitis—10%; late grade 2 pulmonary toxicity of 5.5% and a grade 4 bronchostenosis |
McAvoy et al. [2014] | 102 | NSCLC | I: 29/102; II: 16/102; III: 45/102; IV: 9/102 | 17 | 70 | 60.5 | Median local failure free survival of 11.4-month | 14.7 (10.3–20.6) | 45% of patients received chemotherapy; 5% underwent surgery; 3% underwent surgery and chemotherapy prior to reRT; | ≥ acute grade 3 toxicities, 7% esophageal, 10% pulmonary |
Chao et al. [2016] | 57 | NSCLC | I: 12/57; II: 4/57; III: 35/57; IV: 6/57; | 19 | Not described | 66.6 | PFS 58% at 1 year | 14.9 (NS) | 67% of patients received concurrent chemotherapy with reRT | ≥ acute grade 3 toxicities in 39% of patients, ≥ late grade 3 toxicities reported in 12% of patients; 6 grade 5 toxicities observed |
Ho et al. [2017] | 27 | NSCLC (81.4%), Other (18.6%) | I: 7/27; II: 4/27; III: 16/27; | 29.5 | 60 | 66 | Median freedom from local failure of 78% at 1 year | 18 (NS) | 48% of patients received concurrent chemotherapy with reRT | Acute grade 3 pulmonary toxicity in 7% of patients, no ≥ acute grade 3 esophageal toxicity |
Badiyan et al. Abstract [2017] | 67 | NSCLC (90%), SCLC (10%) | Not described | 21 | 59.4 or 50 SBRT (3–5 fractions) | 60 | Median PFS of 7.9 months and 26% at 1 year | 13.2 (NS) | 84% of patients received chemotherapy prior to reRT; 30% received concurrent chemotherapy with reRT | Acute grade 3 toxicity in 3% of patients (pneumonia and neck pain), 1% late grade 3 fatigue; no grade 4 toxicities and one death 4.5 months from reRT |
NSCLC, non-small cell lung cancer; SCLC, small cell lung cancer; NS, not stated; EBRT, external beam radiation therapy; IMRT, intensity modulated radiation therapy; PBT, proton beam therapy; SBRT, stereotactic body radiation therapy; RT, radiation therapy; reRT, reirradiation therapy; PFS, progression-free survival; LC, local control.