Table 4.
Published medical literature evaluating times to radiotherapy in patients having radiotherapy without chemotherapy, and outcomes for breast cancer
Study | n | Cohort | Inclusion | Delay Groups (weeks unless specified) | Interval without decline (weeks) | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nixon, Int J Rad Oncol Biol Phys 1994 | 653 | Single institution | Stage I, II | <4; 5–8; 9–12 | < 8 | No difference <8 weeks definitive No difference 9–12 weeks uncertain |
Froud, Int J Rad Oncol Biol Phys 2000 | 1,962 | British Columbia Cancer Agency Outcomes Unit Database | T1-3, N0 | 0–5; 6–8; 9–12; 13+ | ≤20 | No difference <20 weeks (>20 unknown-sample too small) |
Hershman, Int J Rad Oncol Biol Phys 2006 | 13,907 | SEER-Medicare, 1991–1999 | Stage I, II | <1; ≥1–<2; ≥2–<3; ≥3 months | <12 | No difference <3 months; DSS HR 3.81; OS HR 1.91 >3 months |
Vujovic, Int J Rad Oncol Biol Phys 2006 | 568 | Single institution | T1-2, N0 | 0–8; >8–12; >12–16; >16 | <16 | No difference <16 weeks definitive No difference >16 weeks uncertain |
Olivotto, J Clin Oncol 2009 | 6,428 | British Columbia Cancer Agency Outcomes Unit Database | T1-2, N0-1 | 0–4, >4–8;>8–12;>12–16; >16–20;>20–42 | ≤20 | No difference in LRFS, DRFS, BCSS ≤20 weeks; HRs >20 weeks: LRFS NS; DRFS 1.86; BCSS 2.15 |
Punglia, BMJ 2010 | 18,050 | SEER-Medicare 1991–2002 | Stage 0-II | Continuous modeling | <6 | Time to XRT >6 weeks: HR 1.19 HR 1.005 for LR per day |
Karlsson, Int J Rad Oncol Biol Phys 2011 | 964 | Data from 3 IBCSG Trials (Trials VII, VIII, IX) | Any T, N± | ≤48, 49–77; 78–112; ≥113 days | ≤20 | No difference <20 weeks |
IBCSG = International Breast Cancer Study Group; d = days; LRFS = local recurrence-free survival; DRFS = distant recurrence-free survival; BCSS = breast cancer-specific survival; HR = hazard ratio; NS = nonsignificant; LR = local recurrence