Skip to main content
. 2018 Sep 5;13(9):e0203591. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0203591

Table 2. Summary of intervention effects for comparisons with delayed (>24h) retention intervals.

Study/Experiment Comparison Significant group differences (implicit vs explicit group)
Motor ST Motor DT Cognitive DT Motor DTC Cognitive DTC Declarative knowledge
Abdoli et al. (2012) [39] Errorless vs Errorful + + = + N/A +
Sanli et al. (2014)—Experiment 1-Test Phase 2 [53] Errorless vs Errorful = = = = N/A N/A
Sanli et al. (2014)—Experiment 2-Test Phase 2 [53] Errorless vs Errorful = = = = N/A N/A
Orrell et al. (2006b)—Test phase 2 [48] Errorless vs Explicit = = = ? N/A +
Koedijker et al. (2008)—Test phase 2 [41] Analogy vs Explicit = = = = N/A +
Lam et al.(2009a) [42] Analogy vs Explicit = = = = N/A +
Lam et al.(2009b) [30] Analogy vs Explicit = + = + N/A +
Orrell et al. (2006b)—Test phase 2 [48] Analogy vs Explicit - - = ? N/A +
Totsika et al. (2003) [57] External vs Internal + + N/A ? N/A N/A
Wulf et al. (2001) [15] External vs Internal + + + = + N/A

NB: Green ‘+’: Significantly (p<0.05) better performance or less declarative knowledge for implicit group compared to explicit group; Yellow ‘-’: Significantly (p<0.05) better performance or more declarative knowledge for explicit group compared to implicit group; ‘ = ‘: No significant difference between implicit and explicit groups; ‘?’: Outcome measure was assessed, but corresponding p-values could not be obtained; N/A: Outcome measure not assessed. Abbreviations: DT = dual-task; DTC = dual-task costs.