Table 1.
Study | Population Examined; Main Inclusion Criteria | Method of Group Assignment | Experimental Group Description | Control Group Description | Main Outcome Measures | PEDro Score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pua et al16 | 68 patients; ≥50 years old, history of LBP, BMI <38 kg/m2, evidence of LSS on MRI, no mental impairments, no LSS surgery, no neoplastic conditions, no severe osteoporosis, no vascular or pulmonary disease | Random assignment | Treadmill with body weight support + exercise program | Cycling + exercise program | ODI, Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire, 100-mm VAS, Patient Perceived Benefit | 8/10 |
Goren et al15 | 54 patients; MRI-proven LSS, back and/or leg pain, standing or walking pain, over 18 years old, symptoms lasting over 3 months, neurogenic claudication within 15 minutes on treadmill | Random assignment | Ultrasound + exercise/sham ultrasound + exercise | No exercise + no ultrasound | Pain, disability, functional capacity, consumption of analgesic, ODI, Wilcoxon’s rank test and disability index | 7/10 |
Koc et al29 | 33 patients; diagnosed with LSS, no heart disease, no past spinal surgery, no vertebral fracture, no progressive neurologic deficit, no cauda equine | Random assignment | Physical therapy treatment/epidural steroid injections | No treatment | FFD, treadmill walk test, sit-to-stand test, weight carrying test, Roland-Morris Disability Index, Nottingham Health Profile | 6/10 |
Whitman et al21 | 58 patients; LSS diagnosis, pain in lumbopelvic region and lower extremities, over 50 years old, patient rating of sitting being more comfortable than standing or walking, no previous LSS surgery, no artery disease | Random assignment | Manual physical therapy treatment, body-supported treadmill walking, exercise | Lumbar flexion exercises, treadmill walking program, subtherapeutic ultrasound | Global rating of change scale, ODI, Numerical Pain Rating Scale, Satisfaction Pain Rating Scale, treadmill test | 8/10 |
Sculco et al27 | 34 patients; 25-65 years old, not involved in exercise routine, good health, no medical or psychological issues that could affect aerobic exercise, willing to follow exercise intervention, no acute low back pain, no surgical intervention for LBP in the last 6 months | Matched stratified | Aerobic exercise | No exercise | Profile of Mood States, Brief Pain Inventory, medical office visits for pain/symptoms, physical therapy treatment referrals, prescription of pain medication, work status | 2/10 |
Abbreviations: LBP, low back pain; BMI, body mass index; LSS, lumbar spinal stenosis; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; ODI, Oswestry Disability Index; VAS, Visual Analog Scale; FFD, Finger Floor Distance.