Skip to main content
. 2018 Aug;7(4):242–250. doi: 10.21037/hbsn.2017.12.01

Table 3. Operative comfort between colorectal and non-colorectal specialists.

Question Variables Colorectal (%) Non-colorectal (%) P value
Would you consider performing a right hemicolectomy with the following? Segmental hepatectomy (ies) 91.7 85.0 0.18
Hepatic lobectomy 66.7 75.0 0.17
Extended hepatic lobectomy 54.2 30.0 ≤0.01*
Would you consider performing a left hemicolectomy with the following? Segmental hepatectomy (ies) 87.5 85.0 0.33
Hepatic lobectomy 58.3 55.0 0.34
Extended hepatic lobectomy 37.5 15.0 ≤0.01*
Would you consider performing a low anterior resection with the following? Segmental hepatectomy (ies) 62.5 70.0 0.21
Hepatic lobectomy 45.8 20.0 ≤0.01*
Extended hepatic lobectomy 25.0 5.0 ≤0.01*
Would you consider performing an abdominoperineal resection with the following? Segmental hepatectomy (ies) 58.3 65.0 0.24
Hepatic lobectomy 50.0 30.0 0.01*
Extended hepatic lobectomy 20.8 10.0 0.03*
If there is a role for concurrent resection, how often do you protect your anastomosis with a diverting stoma? Never 0.0 0.0 N/A
Rarely 38.1 14.3 ≤0.01*
Occasionally 52.4 57.1 0.66
Often 4.8 28.6 0.02*
Always 4.8 0.0 N/A
Would you consider performing stage I of a planned 2-stage hepatectomy in the context of a concurrent colorectal primary resection if your preferred tenets to the above answers are maintained? 94.4 83.3 0.21
In a patient with symptomatic colorectal primary and synchronous hepatic metastases, is there any role for (select all that apply)? Neoadjuvant chemotherapy 62.5 50.0 0.18
Preoperative colorectal stenting 54.2 63.6 0.27
Concurrent colorectal and hepatic resections 62.5 63.6 0.66

SH, segmental hepatectomy; HL, hepatic lobectomy; EHL, extended hepatic lobectomy; N/A, non-applicable.