Table 2.
Assessment tools | Rigour in older cancer patients | Variables used to code deficits for FI | Deficit Total |
---|---|---|---|
Cumulative Index Scale-Geriatrics (CIRS-G) | Confirmed criterion validity [27], good concurrent construct and validity [27], intrarater reliability r = 0.83 and interrater reliability r = 0.81[27, 28] | • Comorbidities coded as deficit (=1) for each comorbidity up to a maximum of 12 | 12 |
Malnutrition Screening Tool (MST) | Sensitivity 100% [29]; specificity 81–92% [29]; PPV 0.4–0.8[29]; NPV = 1.0[29]; IRR good [29] | • BMI Weight (kg)/Height (m2) outside normal range (< 22 or > 27) = 1 • Weight loss ≥6 kg = 1 • Decreased appetite = 1 |
3 |
Standardised Mini-mental State (SMMSE) | Reliability α = 0.65–0.732[30]; sensitivity 91% [31]; specificity 91% [31] | • Cognitive impairment - Mild (MMSE 20–25) = 0.5 - Moderate/severe (MMSE< 20) = 1 |
1 |
Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS) | Sensitivity 96% [31] and specificity 88% [31] | • GDS score ≥ 5 = 1 | 1 |
Modified Barthel Index (MBI) | Criterion and construct validity established [32]; test-retest reliability r = 0.7[32]; inter-rater reliability r = 0.99[32] | • ADL (personal hygiene, bathing, feeding, toileting, stairs, dressing, ambulation, transfers) - Minimal help required = 0.5 - Moderate help required /Unable to do = 1 |
8 |
• Continence (bowel and bladder) - Minimal help required = 0.5 - Moderate help required /Unable to do = 1 |
2 | ||
Lawton IADL Scale (IADL) | Inter-rater reliability r = 0.85[33]; reliability α = 0.86[33] | • IADL (phone use, shopping, food preparation, house- keeping, laundry, transport, medications, finances) - Minimal help required = 0.5 - Moderate help required /Unable to do = 1 |
8 |
Vulnerable Elders Survey-13 | Validity established [15]; reliability α = 0.90[15]; sensitivity 90% and specificity 70% [15] | • Self-rated health fair/poor = 1 | 1 |
• Physical performance measures (stooping, lifting, reaching, writing, walking, housework) - A little/some difficulty - A lot of difficulty/Unable to do |
6 |