Skip to main content
. 2018 Feb 19;96(4):1362–1374. doi: 10.1093/jas/sky030

Table 4.

Fermentor pH, VFA concentration and molar proportion, and CH4 output of annual ryegrass, canola, rapeseed, and turnip fed with orchardgrass during continuous culture fermentation

Item Diet* SEM
ARG CAN RAP TUR
pH
 Mean 6.61 6.29 6.41 6.57 0.142
 Minimum 6.40a 6.08b 6.14a,b 6.16a,b 0.078
 Maximum 6.95 6.73 7.04 6.69 0.201
Total VFA, mM 90.2 84.8 88.9 84.9 4.68
Individual VFA, mol/100 mol
 Acetate (A) 48.10 42.30 45.14 42.72 2.353
 Propionate (P) 25.82a 22.28b 21.80b 23.66a,b 1.092
 Butyrate (B) 11.44a 15.53a,b 16.80b 14.21a,b 1.478
 Isobutyrate 0.84a 0.39b 0.42b 0.43b 0.044
 Valerate (V) 3.22a 3.98a,b 4.37b 3.55a,b 0.256
 Isovalerate 0.74a 0.30b 0.33b 0.32b 0.047
 A:P 1.86a 1.90a 2.08b 1.80a 0.049
 A + B:P + V 2.05a 2.20a,b 2.36b 2.09a 0.057
CH4
 mg CH4/d 68.9a 13.1b 7.4b 13.1b 5.77
 mg of CH4/g of OM fed 0.94a 0.18b 0.18b 0.10b 0.079
 mg of CH4/g of NDF fed 2.37a 0.56b 0.31b 0.55b 0.204
 mg of CH4/g of digestible OM fed 2.22a 0.30b 0.22b 0.37b 0.139
 mg of CH4/g of digestible NDF fed 1.37a 0.25b 0.14b 0.24b 0.119

*ARG = 50% orchardgrass + 50% annual ryegrass; CAN = 50% orchardgrass + 50% canola; RAP = 50% orchardgrass + 50% rapeseed; TUR = 50% orchardgrass + 50% turnip.

a–cWithin a row, means without a common superscript differ (P ≤ 0.05).