Table 2.
Overview of clinical and preclinically tested viral vaccines for cancer.
| Poxviridae | Adenoviridae | Retroviridae | Togaviridae | Rhabdoviridae | Paramyxoviridae | AAV | Coronaviridae | Papillomaviridae | Baculoviridae | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Genomic material | dsDNA | dsDNA | ssRNA | ssRNA | ssRNA | ssRNA | ssDNA | ssRNA | circular DNA | circular DNA |
| Insert capacity | >30 kb | < 7.5 kb (though HC-AdV 35 kb) | 12 kb | 8 kb | 6 kb | 6 kb | < 4 kb | 6 kb | 8 kb | >38 kb |
| Production (titers) | High | High | Moderate | High | High | Low | High | Low | Low to high | High |
| Efficacy of tg delivery to DCs | Broad tropism | Serotype dependent tropsm, infects dividing and non-dividing cells, transient expression | Psedotype dpendent tropism, infects dividing or/and non-dividing cells, stable integration with long term expression | Broad tropism with strong neuronal preference + high expression level | Broad tropism, highly transient expression | No | Serotype dependent tropsm, infects dividing and non-dividing cells, slow expression onset | DC-specific tropism | Epithelial tropism | Broad tropism |
| DC stimulatory potential | High | High | Wild type low, but attenuated vector high | Low but cytotoxic | Wild type low, but attenuated vector high | Induction of DC maturation | Moderate | High | High | High |
| Pre-existing immunity | High | High | Low | Low | Low | High | Moderate | Most likely high | Most likely high | Low (but serum complement inactivation) |
| Biosafety level | BSL-2 | BSL-2 | BSL2-3 | BSL-1-2 | BSL-2 | BSL-1 | BSL-1 | BSL-2 | BSL-2 | BSL1-2 |
| Clinical phase as vaccine | Phase I-III | Phase I-II | Phase I-II | Phase I-II | FDA-approved | Phase I | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable |