Table 1.
Study | Population | Analyzed compounds | Levels | Design and timing of exposure | Exposure assessment | Timing of outcomes | Reproductive outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Burns et al., 2016 [41] | 473 Russian boys (Chapaevsk) | Dioxins, furans, dioxin-like PCBs | Wide range ΣDLC, median 362 pg/g lipid ΣTEQ, median 21.1 pg TEQ/g lipid |
Longitudinal, 8–9 years, 2003–2005 | Serum concentrations and TEQ | 8–18 years, 2003–2015 | Delayed pubertal onset and sexual maturity by testicular volume and genitalia staging. |
Den Hond et al., 2002 [36] | 80 Flemish boys in 3 areas, 2 exposed and one control | DLCs | CALUX assay, geometric means 0.15–0.20 in 3 areas | Cross-sectional, 15.8–19.6 Years | CALUX assay | 15.8–19.6 years | No effect on pubertal staging. |
Faure et al., 2014 [51] | 251 French men-patients of infertility clinic | Dioxins | - | Longitudinal, adulthood, 1971–2007 | Atmospheric diffusion model around the municipal waste incinerator in two periods, high and low emission | Adulthood, 2001–2003 and 2004–2007 | Increased abnormal spermatozoa. |
Guo et al., 2000 [38] | 35 Taiwanese young adults (Yu-Cheng and unexposed) | PCBs, PCDFs | - | Longitudinal, prenatal and lactational, 1978–1998 | Serum concentrations in mothers and children | 16–18 years, 1998 | Increased abnormal sperm morphology, decreased motility, decreased hamster oocyte penetration. |
Guo et al., 2004 [37] | 110 Taiwanese boys (Yu-Cheng and unexposed) | PCBs, PCDFs | Mothers: 2,3,4,7,8-Pe CDF, 6940 pg/g lipid; Children: PnCDF, 89pg/g/lipid |
Longitudinal, prenatal and lactational, 1978–1991 | Estimated (in mothers) and measured (in children) serum concentrations | 11–14 years, 1991–1993 | Decreased penile length. |
Henriksen et al., 1996 [59] | 1006 U.S. men (veterans of Operation Ranch Hand and unexposed) | Agent Orange, TCDD | TCDD median 130ppt | Longitudinal, adulthood, 1962–1971 | Serum concentrations | 37–74 years, 1982, 1985, 1987, 1992 | No effect on testosterone, follicle stimulating hormone (FSH), luteinizing hormone (LH), testicular abnormalities, sperm count, sperm abnormalities. |
Hsu et al., 2003 [39] | 68 Taiwanese young men (Yu-Cheng and unexposed) | PCBs, PCDFs | - | Adulthood | Serum concentration | 37–50 years | Increased abnormal sperm morphology, decreased motility, decreased hamster oocyte penetration. |
Korrick et al., 2011 [40] | 499 Russian boys (Chapaevsk) | Dioxins | Wide range Medians, pg/TEQ/g lipid for TCDD - 2.8; PCDDTEQ-8.2 |
Longitudinal, 8–9 years; 2003–2005 | Serum concentrations and TEQ | 8–12 years, 2003–2006 | Delayed pubertal onsetby testicular volume |
Minguez-Alarcon et al.,2016 [55] | 133 Russian young adults (Chapaevsk) | TCDD, dioxins | Wide range Medians, pg/TEQ/g lipid for TCDD-2.9; PCDDTEQ-8.7 |
Longitudinal, 8–9 years; 2003–2005 | Serum concentrations and TEQ | 18–19 years, 2012–2015 | Decreased sperm count, total sperm count and total motile sperm count. |
Mocarelli et al., 2008 [13] | 319 Italian men (Seveso accident and unexposed) | TCDD | Medians, ppt 1–9 years - 210; 10–17 years - 164: 18–26 years - 123 |
Longitudinal, three age groups: 1–9 years 10–17 years 18–26 years; 1976 |
Serum concentration | Three age groups: 22–31 years 32–39 years 40–47 years |
Exposed at 1–9 years - decreased sperm count, motility, estradiol, increased
FSH Exposed at 10–17 years - increased total sperm count, total motile sperm count, FSH, reduced estradiol Exposed at 18–26 years - no effects. |
Mocarelli et al., 2011 [50] | 97 Italian men (Seveso accident breast-fed, formula-fed and un xposed) | TCDD | Median, ppt at conception -breast-fed - 19.0: formula-fed - 27.9 |
Longitudinal, prenatal and lactational, 1976–1983 | Maternal serum concentrations | 18–26 years, 2002–2003 | In breast-fed group - decreased sperm count, total sperm count and progressive motility, increased FSH, decreased inhibin B. |
Paoli et al., 2015 [53] | 125 testicular cancer patients and 103 controls | PCBs | - | Adulthood | Serum concentrations | Adulthood | Decreased sperm concentration count and motility, increased abnormalspermatozoa. |