Table 2. Characteristics of included studies.
Study | Study type | Setting and time | Ages of adolescents Ages of comparison group |
Inclusion and exclusion criteria | Outcomes and definitions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ujah et al. 2005 | Patient record review | Jos University Teaching Hospital, Nigeria Jan 1985-Dec 2001 |
≤15 20–24 |
Not reported | Maternal deaths; women who died during pregnancy or childbirth in the maternity ward of the hospital |
Wort et al. 2006 | Cross-sectional patient record review | Kilosa Hospital, Tanzania June 2001- October 2002 |
≤15, n = 34 ≥20, n = 281 |
Inclusion: vaginal births Exclusions: Twin births, stillbirths, cesarean section. Unclear whether triplets excluded. |
Low birth weight, <2500 g |
Van Dillen et al. 2008 | Retrospective patient record review |
Onandjokwe Lutheran Hospital, Namibia February 2002 –August 2002 |
14–17, n = 76 ≥20, n = 371 |
Inclusion: Primiparous women, singleton births Exclusion: Twin births, unknown age of mother |
Low birth weight, <2500 g Perinatal mortality; all deaths occurring after 28 weeks gestation with weight greater or equal to 1000 g Maternal mortality Stillbirth (macerated) |
Adam et al. 2009 | Cross-sectional descriptive study | Khartoum teaching hospital, Sudan October 2007 –January 2008 |
≤16, n = 29 20–24, n = 203 |
Inclusion: Primiparous women, singleton births Exclusion: > 24 years old |
Preterm birth, <37 weeks of gestation Low birth weight, <2500 g |
Nkwabong et al. 2009 | Retrospective patient record review | Yaoundé Teaching Hospital, Cameroon January 2004 –December 2004 |
≤15, n = 11 16, n = 13 17, n = 21 20–25, n = 403 |
Inclusion: Nulliparous teenagers or women aged 20–25 years old | Early neonatal death |
Adeyinka et al. 2010 | Retrospective case-control study, patient record review | The University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria January 2007 –November 2008 |
<18, n = 45 20–35, n = 90 |
Inclusion: Adolescents aged <18 years old or adults aged between 20 and 35 | Pre-eclampsia* Eclampsia** Low birth weight, <2500 g Stillbirths |
Zeck et al. 2010 | Retrospective patient record review | The Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, Moshi, Tanzania. | <18, n = 209 22–27, n = 1341 |
Inclusion: Primiparas Within the set age categories |
Intrauterine fetal death LBW, <2500 g at term Preeclampsia at the time of delivery |
Tebeu et al. 2011 | Case-control study, patient record review | Maroua Regional Hospital, Cameroon June 2005 –May 2007 |
13–16, n = 53 20–34, n = 330 |
Inclusion: Cases had hypertensive disorders in pregnancy Exclusion: Twin gestations, chronic hypertension |
Pre-eclampsia/eclampsia*** |
Ganchimeg et al. 2013 | Secondary analysis using facility-based cross-sectional patient record data from the WHO Global Survey on Maternal and Perinatal Health | Health institutions in 24 countries in Africa, Latin America and Asia. Africa: Algeria, Angola, Democratic republic of Congo, Niger, Nigeria, Kenya and Uganda. 2004–2005 in Africa |
Africa: ≤15, n = 551 20–24, n = 10242 |
Inclusion: Health institutions with ≥1000 deliveries per year and capable of performing caesarean sections. Nulliparous women ≤24 years of age Singleton neonate of BW ≥500 g or gestational age ≥22 weeks if BW was missing |
Low birthweight, <2500 g Preterm birth; births <37 completed weeks of gestation. Perinatal death**** Maternal deaths; intra-hospital deaths occurring on or before the 8th day postpartum |
Lukonga et al. 2015 | Cross-sectional population based data | National household survey Zambia Demographic and Health survey (ZDHS) 2007 |
12–17, n = 2649 (# of births) 25–29, n = 233 (# of births) |
Inclusion: Women who gave birth to live infants within 5 years preceeding the survey Available and complete records of the babies for the first 28 days Exclusion: Incomplete or missing records for the baby |
Neonatal death, up to 28 days postpartum |
Banda et al. 2015 | Cross-sectional data | Zambia. Data from national population census 2010, | 10–14 20–24 |
Pregnancy-related deaths: Death of a woman while pregnant or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy | |
Ibrahim et al. 2015 | Retrospective patient record review. Purposive sampling method from birth registry folders | Tamale Teaching Hospital, Northern Ghana, data collected from 2000 and 2010 | <18, n = 12 25–34, n = 761 |
Low birth weight, <2500 g | |
De Wet et al. 2016 | Secondary data analysis of Death Notification Forms (DNF) | South Africa. DNFs and household surveys from 2006–2012. | 10–14 20–24 |
Inclusion: Completed forms where the deceased was female and pregnancy status was confirmed | Maternal death: Direct maternal causes of death while pregnant Pregnancy-related deaths: All deaths while pregnant |
Njim et al. 2016 | Retrospective patient record review | Bueau Regional Hospital, South-West region of Cameroon Jan. 2007 –Dec. 2012 |
≤16, n = 78 ≥20, n = 4450 |
Inclusion: Complete records of women who gave birth at the hospital Exclusion: Gestational age <28 completed weeks, multiple gestations, incomplete information |
Preterm delivery Low birth weight |
Mombo-Ngoma et al. 2016 | Prospective multinational cohort study | Data from a RCT (MiPPAD) in Benin, Gabon, Mozambique and Tanzania Sept 2009 –Dec.2013 |
≤16, n = 248 20–30, n = 2376 |
Inclusion: HIV negative women, gestational age (GA) <28 weeks at first ANC visit, willing to participate and give birth at the study health facility Exclusion: Allergy to any of the study drugs. Any other ongoing serious condition. Stillbirths, multiple gestations. Tanzania data on PTD was excluded in the paper because of a systematic error in the assessment of GA |
Low birth weight, <2500 g Preterm delivey, <37 completed weeks of gestation, estimated at ANC visit with bimanual palpation, and at delivery by the Ballard score |
Moodley et al. 2016 | Cross-sectional patient record review | A regional hospital in Durban, South Africa. July–Dec. 2011 and Jan.–June 2014 | <18, n = 827 25–34, n = 3662 |
Inclusion: Women with viable pregnancies delivering neonate >_500 g with recorded birth outcomes Exclusion: Multiple births |
Premature births, <37 completed weeks of gestation Low birth weight, <2500 g Stillbirth Small for gestational age (gestational age at delivery based on mothers last normal menstrual period, or ultrasound, or a combination of both) |
Mombo-Ngoma et al. 2017 | Analysis of two prospective cohort studies (MiPPAD and IDEA) |
Two health institutions in Lambaréne and Fougamou, Gabon Sept 2009 –Nov. 2013 |
≤16, n = 66 20–30, n = 587 |
Inclusion: Participation in MiPPAD or IDEA trials Exclusion: Missing delivery data, miscarriage or stillbirth, multiple gestations |
Low birth weight, <2500 g |
Tessema et al. 2017 | Secondary data from Global burden of Disease study from 2013. | Ethiopia, 1990–2013. Various data sources; sibling stories, censuses, maternal mortality surveillance and verbal autopsy analysis. |
10–14 20–24 25–29 |
Maternal death: Death of a woman while pregnant or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy |
* Hypertension (140/90 mmHg on two occasions 4h apart) and proteinuria (0,3g/dl) in the second half of pregnancy
** Associated with convulsions, oliguria (4400ml/24h), increased tendon reflex, pain in the right hypochondriac region
*** Women with a diastolic blood pressure of at least 90 mmHg or a systolic BP of at least 140 mmHg were considered to have hypertensive disorder in pregnancy
**** Perinatal deaths included fresh and macerated stillbirths and early neonatal deaths, defined as the inta-hospital death of a liveborn neonate during the first 7 days after delivery or earlier if the discharge occurred before 7 days