Skip to main content
. 2018 Sep 26;13(9):e0204327. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0204327

Table 2. Characteristics of included studies.

Study Study type Setting and time Ages of adolescents
Ages of comparison group
Inclusion and exclusion criteria Outcomes and definitions
Ujah et al. 2005 Patient record review Jos University Teaching Hospital, Nigeria
Jan 1985-Dec 2001
≤15
20–24
Not reported Maternal deaths; women who died during pregnancy or childbirth in the maternity ward of the hospital
Wort et al. 2006 Cross-sectional patient record review Kilosa Hospital, Tanzania
June 2001- October 2002
≤15, n = 34
≥20, n = 281
Inclusion: vaginal births
Exclusions: Twin births, stillbirths, cesarean section. Unclear whether triplets excluded.
Low birth weight, <2500 g
Van Dillen et al. 2008 Retrospective patient record review
Onandjokwe Lutheran Hospital, Namibia
February 2002 –August 2002
14–17, n = 76
≥20, n = 371
Inclusion: Primiparous women, singleton births
Exclusion: Twin births, unknown age of mother
Low birth weight, <2500 g
Perinatal mortality;
all deaths occurring after 28 weeks gestation with weight greater or equal to 1000 g
Maternal mortality
Stillbirth (macerated)
Adam et al. 2009 Cross-sectional descriptive study Khartoum teaching hospital, Sudan
October 2007 –January 2008
≤16, n = 29
20–24, n = 203
Inclusion: Primiparous women, singleton births
Exclusion: > 24 years old
Preterm birth, <37 weeks of gestation
Low birth weight, <2500 g
Nkwabong et al. 2009 Retrospective patient record review Yaoundé Teaching Hospital, Cameroon
January 2004 –December 2004
≤15, n = 11
16, n = 13
17, n = 21
20–25, n = 403
Inclusion: Nulliparous teenagers or women aged 20–25 years old Early neonatal death
Adeyinka et al. 2010 Retrospective case-control study, patient record review The University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria
January 2007 –November 2008
<18, n = 45
20–35, n = 90
Inclusion: Adolescents aged <18 years old or adults aged between 20 and 35 Pre-eclampsia*
Eclampsia**
Low birth weight, <2500 g
Stillbirths
Zeck et al. 2010 Retrospective patient record review The Kilimanjaro Christian Medical Centre, Moshi, Tanzania. <18, n = 209
22–27, n = 1341
Inclusion: Primiparas
Within the set age categories
Intrauterine fetal death
LBW, <2500 g at term
Preeclampsia at the time of delivery
Tebeu et al. 2011 Case-control study, patient record review Maroua Regional Hospital, Cameroon
June 2005 –May 2007
13–16, n = 53
20–34, n = 330
Inclusion: Cases had hypertensive disorders in pregnancy
Exclusion: Twin gestations, chronic hypertension
Pre-eclampsia/eclampsia***
Ganchimeg et al. 2013 Secondary analysis using facility-based cross-sectional patient record data from the WHO Global Survey on Maternal and Perinatal Health Health institutions in 24 countries in Africa, Latin America and Asia. Africa: Algeria, Angola, Democratic republic of Congo, Niger, Nigeria, Kenya and Uganda.
2004–2005 in Africa
Africa: ≤15, n = 551
20–24, n = 10242
Inclusion: Health institutions with ≥1000 deliveries per year and capable of performing caesarean sections.
Nulliparous women
≤24 years of age
Singleton neonate of BW ≥500 g or gestational age ≥22 weeks if BW was missing
Low birthweight, <2500 g
Preterm birth; births <37 completed weeks of gestation.
Perinatal death****
Maternal deaths; intra-hospital deaths occurring on or before the 8th day postpartum
Lukonga et al. 2015 Cross-sectional population based data National household survey Zambia Demographic and Health survey (ZDHS)
2007
12–17, n = 2649 (# of births)
25–29, n = 233 (# of births)
Inclusion: Women who gave birth to live infants within 5 years preceeding the survey
Available and complete records of the babies for the first 28 days
Exclusion: Incomplete or missing records for the baby
Neonatal death, up to 28 days postpartum
Banda et al. 2015 Cross-sectional data Zambia. Data from national population census 2010, 10–14
20–24
Pregnancy-related deaths: Death of a woman while pregnant or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy
Ibrahim et al. 2015 Retrospective patient record review. Purposive sampling method from birth registry folders Tamale Teaching Hospital, Northern Ghana, data collected from 2000 and 2010 <18, n = 12
25–34, n = 761
Low birth weight, <2500 g
De Wet et al. 2016 Secondary data analysis of Death Notification Forms (DNF) South Africa. DNFs and household surveys from 2006–2012. 10–14
20–24
Inclusion: Completed forms where the deceased was female and pregnancy status was confirmed Maternal death: Direct maternal causes of death while pregnant
Pregnancy-related deaths: All deaths while pregnant
Njim et al. 2016 Retrospective patient record review Bueau Regional Hospital, South-West region of Cameroon
Jan. 2007 –Dec. 2012

≤16, n = 78
≥20, n = 4450
Inclusion: Complete records of women who gave birth at the hospital
Exclusion: Gestational age <28 completed weeks, multiple gestations, incomplete information
Preterm delivery
Low birth weight
Mombo-Ngoma et al. 2016 Prospective multinational cohort study Data from a RCT (MiPPAD) in Benin, Gabon, Mozambique and Tanzania
Sept 2009 –Dec.2013
≤16, n = 248
20–30, n = 2376
Inclusion: HIV negative women, gestational age (GA) <28 weeks at first ANC visit, willing to participate and give birth at the study health facility
Exclusion: Allergy to any of the study drugs. Any other ongoing serious condition. Stillbirths, multiple gestations. Tanzania data on PTD was excluded in the paper because of a systematic error in the assessment of GA
Low birth weight, <2500 g
Preterm delivey, <37 completed weeks of gestation, estimated at ANC visit with bimanual palpation, and at delivery by the Ballard score
Moodley et al. 2016 Cross-sectional patient record review A regional hospital in Durban, South Africa. July–Dec. 2011 and Jan.–June 2014 <18, n = 827
25–34, n = 3662
Inclusion: Women with viable pregnancies delivering neonate >_500 g with recorded birth outcomes
Exclusion: Multiple births
Premature births, <37 completed weeks of gestation
Low birth weight, <2500 g
Stillbirth
Small for gestational age (gestational age at delivery based on mothers last normal menstrual period, or ultrasound, or a combination of both)
Mombo-Ngoma et al. 2017 Analysis of two prospective cohort studies
(MiPPAD and IDEA)
Two health institutions in Lambaréne and Fougamou,
Gabon
Sept 2009 –Nov. 2013
≤16, n = 66
20–30, n = 587
Inclusion: Participation in MiPPAD or IDEA trials
Exclusion: Missing delivery data, miscarriage or stillbirth, multiple gestations
Low birth weight, <2500 g
Tessema et al. 2017 Secondary data from Global burden of Disease study from 2013. Ethiopia, 1990–2013.
Various data sources; sibling stories, censuses, maternal mortality surveillance and verbal autopsy analysis.
10–14
20–24
25–29
Maternal death: Death of a woman while pregnant or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy

* Hypertension (140/90 mmHg on two occasions 4h apart) and proteinuria (0,3g/dl) in the second half of pregnancy

** Associated with convulsions, oliguria (4400ml/24h), increased tendon reflex, pain in the right hypochondriac region

*** Women with a diastolic blood pressure of at least 90 mmHg or a systolic BP of at least 140 mmHg were considered to have hypertensive disorder in pregnancy

**** Perinatal deaths included fresh and macerated stillbirths and early neonatal deaths, defined as the inta-hospital death of a liveborn neonate during the first 7 days after delivery or earlier if the discharge occurred before 7 days