Table 1.
Study | Study Population | Fracture Type/Site | No. of Patients, by HIV/HCV Status | Incidence Rate of Fracture | Risk of Fracture (Hazard Ratio [95% CI]) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lo Re (2012) [3] | Men, women | Hip | HCV/HIV (N=36,950) HCV (N=276,901) HIV (N=95,827) Uninfected (N=3,110,904) |
3.06/1000 patient-years 2.69/1000 patient-years 1.95/1000 patient-years 1.29/1000 patient-years |
HCV/HIV vs HCV: 1.38 (1.25–1.53) HCV/HIV vs HIV: Female: 1.76 (1.44–2.16) Male: 1.36 (1.20–1.55) HCV/HIV vs Uninfected: Female: 2.65 (2.21–3.17) Male: 2.20 (1.97–2.47). |
Maalouf (2013) [12] | Men | Hip, wrist, vertebra | HIV/HCV (N=17,762) HIV (N=38,898) |
2.57/1000 patient-years 2.07/1000 patient-years |
HCV/HIV vs HIV: 1.24 |
Hansen (2012)[5] | General population | Low-energy fractures | HIV/HCV (N=851) HIV (N=4,455) Uninfected (N=26,530) |
17.7/1000 patient-years 7.4/1000 patient-years 4.8/1000 patient-years |
HCV/HIV vs. uninfected: 3.8 (3.0–4.9) |
Yin (2010) [16] | Post-menopausal Women | Self-reported fragility and non-fragility fractures | HIV/HCV (N=438) HIV(N=1,290) Uninfected (N=567) |
NR | HCV/HIV vs. HIV: 2.0 (1.49–2.70) |
Young (2011) [14] | Men, women | All fractures | HIV/HCV (NR)* HIV (NR)* |
NR | HCV/HIV vs. HIV: 2.18 (1.12–4.26) |
Yin (2012) [15] | Peri-menopausal women | Self-reported fragility and non-fragility fractures | HIV/HCV (N=434) HIV(N=4,206) |
NR | HCV/HIV vs. HIV: 2.2 (1.2–4.1) |
Yin (2010) [16] | Post-menopausal Women | Self-reported fragility and non-fragility fractures | HIV/HCV (N=438) HIV(N=1,290) Uninfected (N=567) |
NR | HCV/HIV vs. HIV: 2.0 (1.49–2.70) |
Abbreviations: CI=confidence interval; HCV=hepatitis C virus; NR=not reported.
Total study population was 5,826 HIV-infected patients. Number of HCV-co-infected not provided in this report.