Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Nov 16.
Published in final edited form as: Nature. 2018 May 16;557(7705):351–358. doi: 10.1038/s41586-018-0088-0

Table 1 |.

Comparison of current approaches to producing new β-cells

Stem cell differentiation Replication In vivo
reprogramming
Ex vivo
reprogramming
Xenografts Human pancreas
Stage of development Phase I/II clinical Proof-of-concept
with human islets
Proof-of concept
in animal models
Proof-of-concept
With human cells
Proof-of-concept
with pig cells
Concept developmet
in animal models
Advantages Unlimited supply,
Standardized productin
No transplantation
necessary
No transplantation
necessary
Relatively simple
Production process
Unlimitedsupply,
lower cost
Unlimited supply
Tumour risk Moderate (teratoma) High Unknown,
potentially high
Moderate Low Low
Patient specificity Possible with iPS cells Yes Yes Possible with
patient cells
No Possible with iPScells
Issues Complex production
process
Targeted delivery
required
Targeted delivery
required
Stability of cell
product
Targeted delivery
required
Feasibility unknown,
ethical concerns