Skip to main content
. 2018 Sep 20;13:29–37. doi: 10.1016/j.ctro.2018.09.002

Table 1.

Previous studies about potentials of integrating DWI in RT. Purpose – 1: pre-treatment outcome prediction, 2: response assessment, inter-treatment prediction, 3: tumor delineation; Mexp - mono-exponential model, IVIM – intra-voxel incoherent motion; NGK – non-gaussian kurtosis, ADC – apparent diffusion coefficient, ΔADC – difference of inter- or post-treatment ADC to baseline; DTI - diffusion tensor imaging, DCE – dynamic-contrast enhanced imaging.

Purpose Site Author/year citation # patients b-Values in s/mm2 Imaging time point Model Main findings
1 HNSCC Lambrecht 2014 [44] 161 0, 50, 100, 500, 750, 1000 pre-RT Mexp (high-, low- and full b-value range) higher pre-treatment ADC in tumor, when derived from the high b-value range, is related to disease recurrence
1 Noij 2015 [30] 78 0, 750 and 0, 1000 pre-(C) RT Mexp (ADC750, ADC1000) higher pre-treatment ADC1000 in lymph nodes is related to lower disease-free survival
1 Hauser 2013 [53] 22 0, 50, 100, 150, 200, 250, 700, 800 pre-RT IVIM high perfusion fraction f in tumor may be related to poor prognosis
1,2 Rectal cancer Jung 2012 [45] 35 0, 500, 1000 pre- and post-CRT (neoadjuvant) Mexp significant correlation between pre-treatment ADC and tumor volume reduction, as well as between ΔADC and tumor volume reduction
1,2 Lambrecht 2012 [46] 20 0, 50, 100, 500, 750, 1000 pre-, inter-, and post-CRT (neoadjuvant) Mexp pre-treatment ADC as well as inter- and post-treatment ΔADC may be useful for prediction and early assessment of treatment response; pretreatment ADC is significantly lower in patients with pathologic complete response
1 Joye 2017 [47] 85 0, 50, 100, 300, 600, 1000 pre-, inter-, and post-CRT Mexp (high-, low- and full b-value range) DWI is predictive for treatment response; the predictive power can be improved by combining DWI with FDG-PET and T2-weighted volumetry
1 Glioblastoma Pramanik 2015 [48] 21 0, 1000, 3000 pre-CRT no model applied hypercellularity volume as defined on the b = 3000 acquisition is a significant prognostic factor for progression-free survival
1 Cervical cancer Heo 2013 [49] 42 3 0, 500, 1000 pre-CRT Mexp higher mean ADC related to tumor recurrence; 75th percentile ADC predictor for tumor recurrence
1 Onal 2016 [50] 44 0, 800 pre-CRT, post-CRT Mexp lower ADC values pre-RT and post-RT associated to disease recurrence
1 Marconi 2016 [51] 66 0, 600 and 0, 800 pre-CRT Mexp Pre-treatment minimum ADC may be a prognostic factor for disease-free survival
1 Gladwish 2016 [52] 85 0, 50, 400, 1000, and 0, 100, 800 and 0, 50, 400, 800 pre-CRT Mexp 95th percentile ADC might be a metric to predict treatment failure
2 HNSCC Dirix 2009 [56] 15 0, 50, 100, 500, 750, 1000 Pre-, inter-, and post-CRT Mexp lesions showing loco-regional recurrence had a significantly lower inter-treatment ADC
2 King 2013 [57] 30 0, 100, 200, 300, 400, 500 Pre- and inter-CRT Mexp local failure is associated with lower relative increase of ADC compared to local control, as well as with a decrease of skewness and kurtosis in GTV-based ADC histograms
2 Marzi 2015 [65] 34 0, 25, 50, 75, 100, 150, 300, 500, 800 Pre-, inter-, and post-CRT IVIM pre-treatment f and D are independent predictors for shrinkage of major salivary glands
2 Vandecaveye 2012 [66] 29 0, 50, 100, 500, 750, 1000 Pre- and post-CRT Mexp ΔADC three weeks after RT allows for early treatment response assessment
2 Cervical cancer Haack 2015 [59] 11 0, 150, 600, 1000 Pre- and inter-RT Mexp volume with reduced diffusion as derived from DWI changes significantly during treatment, along with a significant mean ADC increase
2 Das 2015 [60] 24 0, 400, 800 Pre- and inter-CRT Mexp inter-treatment ΔADC can be used for early response prediction
2 Zhu 2017 [21] 30 0, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 100, 150, 200, 350, 500, 650, 800, 1000 Pre- and inter-CRT IVIM D at 2 weeks as well as D and f 4 weeks after start of RT prognostic for therapy outcome
2 Daniel 2017 [61] 10 0, 850 Pre-, inter-, and post- CRT Mexp Patient averaged ADCs increased from baseline to follow up, low-ADC regions spatially varied over time
2 Schreuder 2015 [7] 231 (review) mixed Pre-, inter- and post-RT Mexp DWI can be used for early post-RT assessment, but not for early response monitoring
2 Glioma Kassubek 2017 [63] 18 0, 800 Pre- and post-RT DTI DTI can potentially be used to asses irradiation-induced microstructural white matter damage
2 Glioblastoma Nagesh 2008 [64] 25 0, 1000 Pre-, inter- and post-RT DTI DTI has potential for the assessment of radiation-induced white matter injury
2 Chu 2013 [67] 30 0, 1000 and 0, 3000 post-RT Mexp (ADC1000, ADC3000) Fifth percentiles of cumulative histograms of ADC1000 as well as of ADC3000 promising for the differentiation between true progression and pseudo-progression
2 Esophageal cancer van Rossum 2015 [58] 20 0, 200, 800 Pre-, inter-, post-CRT (neoadjuvant) Mexp inter-treatment ΔADC is a predictive factor for histopathologic response
3 Hou 2013 [68] 42 400, 600, 800 pre-treatment no model applied DWI is superior to CT or anatomical MR in GTV delineation
3 Pancreas cancer Kartalis 2016 [26] 15 0, 50, 150, 200, 300, 600, 1000 pre-treatment IVIM, Mexp, NGK ADC and DK might be valuable for differentiating between tumorous and non-tumorous parenchyma
3 Glioblastoma Jensen 2017 [69] 11 0, 1000 pre-RT DTI DTI in combination with a model for the microscopic spread of tumor cells along white matter fiber tracts might be of value for defining the clinical target volume (CTV) of glioblastomas
3 Cervical cancer Schernberg 2017 [70] 44 0, 1000 after CRT, before image guided adaptive brachytherapy no model applied DWI images (without applying quantitative models) might lead to modifications in high-risk clinical target volumes
3 Prostate cancer Langer 2009 [71] 25 0, 600 pre-treatment Mexp ADC is superior to DCE and T2-mapping for differentiating between tumorous and non-tumorous tissue; classification accuracy can be increased by using a multi-parametric model
3 Groenendaal 2012 [72] 87 300, 500, 1000 pre-treatment Mexp Logistic regression-derived model including DWI, DCE can define different risk levels for tumor presence on a voxel level
3 Yu 2017 [73] 140 50, 600, 1000 pre-treatment Mexp Multiparametric model of DWI, T1, and T2 may discriminate between tumorous tissue and normal peripheral zone