Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 8;9:2041731418802090. doi: 10.1177/2041731418802090

Table 1.

Overview of the most significant research comparing different tissues and bioprinting techniques.

Bioink Cell type Results Reference
Skin
Inkjet-based
Collagen type I Fibroblasts
Keratinocytes
Developed a multilayered skin model with multiple cell types Cui and Boland7; Christensen et al.8
PEG Fibroblasts
Keratinocytes
Developed an all-in-one solution for printing skin Ku9
Collagen HMVECs
NHDF
Successfully transplanted printed skin grafts into mice Lee et al.10
Fibrinogen–collagen MSCs Successfully demonstrate in-situ printing to repair full thickness skin wounds on the backs of mice Lee et al.11
Extrusion-based
PDMS Fibroblasts
Keratinocytes
Developed a multilayered epidermal skin layer Cui and Boland7
PCL HDFs
HEKs
Developed a new 3D cell printing strategy to fabricate a 3D skin tissue model Zhu and Liang12
Laser-assisted
Alginate + blood plasma Fibroblasts
Keratinocytes
hMSCs
Performed accurate positioning of multiple cell types Lim et al.13
Bone and cartilage
Inkjet-based
Fibrin/collagen hydrogel Chondrocytes Successfully demonstrated cartilage formation when implanted in mice Xu et al.14
PEGDMA Chondrocytes Used FGF-2 and FGF-2/TGF-β1 doped scaffolds for cartilage development Cui et al.15
PEGDMA Chondrocytes Demonstrated potential for in-situ printing Cui et al.16
Extrusion-based
Matrigel and alginate EPCs
MSCs
Observed bone-like formation in the scaffold 6 weeks after implantation in mice Ozbolat and Hospodiuk17
PCL hASCs Performed craniofacial regeneration Bishop et al.18
GelMA and HAMa IPFP cells Successfully demonstrated reconstruction of chondral defects Fedorovich et al.19
GelMA Chondrocytes Cartilaginous tissue was observed after 4 weeks when implanted in mice Hung et al.20
PCL-alginate gel Chondrocytes Cartilaginous tissue formation was observed in the scaffold when implanted in subcutaneous spaces of mice Oussedik et al.21
Stereolithography
GelMA and nHA Osteoblasts
hMSCs
Developed a 3D bone-mimicking model to study metastasis Zhou et al.22
GelMA and collagen type 1 hMSCs Developed a method to minimize oxygen inhibition Tzeng et al.23
GelMA + PEGDA + TGF-β1 hMSCs Fabricated scaffolds from a precursor hydrolgel, in which cells and nanospheres were suspended Weiß et al.24
Laser-assisted
Sodium alginate Osteosarcoma cells (MG63) Evaluated the effect of 3D positioning of cells on PCL biopapers Morris et al.25
N.A. HUVECs Performed positioning of enothelial cells within osseous biopapers to induce vascularization Williams et al.26
Neural
Inkjet-based
Phosphate-buffered saline CHO and rat embryonic motoneurons Demonstrated successful printing of neural cells using a thermal inkjet printer Xu et al.27
Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium Primary rat embryonic neurons Demonstrated that there was no difference in cell survival rate and neurite growth between printed and non-printed cells Xu et al.28
Extrusion-based
PU NSCs Repaired damaged nervous system in adult zebra fish Chung et al.29
N.A. BMSCs Successfully fabricated purely cellular nerve grafts Pranzo et al.30; Kundu et al.31
Stereolithography
GelMA and graphene nanoplatelets hNSCs Fabricated 3D scaffolds with a homogeneous distribution of cells and graphene nanoplatelets Lu et al.32
Corneal
Extrusion-based
Sodium alginate and collagen Corneal keratinocytes Demonstrated cell viability of KC remained 90% after day 1 of post printing Kim et al.33
Laser-assisted
Collagen I + recombinant laminin hESC-LESCs
hASCs
Performed accurate positioning of multiple cell types Park et al.34
Cardiac
Inkjet-based
Alginate Cardiomyocytes Successfully printed half heart shape with two connected ventricles, showed contract rhythm under electric stimulation Lorber et al.35
Alginate and gelatin gel Endothelial cells Printed tubes, branched tubes, hollow cones, and capillaries with a microscopic porosity Xu et al.36
Fibrin hydrogel HMVEC Achieved confluent cell linings with a ring-shaped microvasculature Nakamura et al.37
Sodium alginate NIH-3T3 Printed vascular shapes using a liquid support material Boland et al.38
Extrusion-based
GelMA iPSCs Developed a microfibrous scaffold capable of spontaneous and synchronous contraction Hsieh et al.39
Me-HA HAVIC Printed scaffold began to be remodeled after 3 days in culture Hsu et al.40
Muscular
Extrusion-based
PEGDA and GelMA NIH-3T3 and C2C12 Successfully implanted in rats Dhariwala et al.41
Stereolithography
PEGDA ESCs and C2C12 Employed dielectrophoresis in cell patterning prior to printing Pati et al.42
Dental
Extrusion-based
GelMA and PEG PDLSCs Successfully demonstrated an array of hydrogel with high cell viability of 94% O’Connell et al.43
PCL and β-TCP Successfully demonstrated the reconstruction of maxillary bone defect in a dog Schuurman et al.44

PEG: polyethylene glycol; 3D: three-dimensional; HMVEC: human microvascular endothelial cell; NHDF: neonatal human dermal fibroblast; MSC: mesenchymal stem cell; PDMS: polydimethylsiloxane; PCL: polycaprolactone; HDF: human dermal fibroblast; HEK: human epidermal keratinocyte; PEGDMA: poly(ethylene glycol) dimethacrylate; FGF: fibroblast growth factor; TGF: transforming growth factor; EPC: endothelial progenitor cell; hASC: human adipose–derived stem cell; HAMa: hyaluronic acid-methacrylate; GelMA: gelatin-methacrylamide; IPFP: infrapatellar fat pad; PEGDA: poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate; CHO: Chinese hamster ovary; PU: polyurethane; NSC: neural stem cell; hMSC: human mesenchymal stem cell; BMSC: bone marrow stem cell; hNSC: human neural stem cell; KC: keratinocyte; LESC: limbal epithelial stem cell; TCP: tricalcium phosphate; iPSC: induced pluripotent stem cell; Me-HA: methacrylated hyaluronic acid; HAVIC: human aortic valvular interstitial cell; PDLSC: periodontal ligament stem cell.