Table 1.
Bioink | Cell type | Results | Reference |
---|---|---|---|
Skin | |||
Inkjet-based | |||
Collagen type I | Fibroblasts Keratinocytes |
Developed a multilayered skin model with multiple cell types | Cui and Boland7; Christensen et al.8 |
PEG | Fibroblasts Keratinocytes |
Developed an all-in-one solution for printing skin | Ku9 |
Collagen | HMVECs NHDF |
Successfully transplanted printed skin grafts into mice | Lee et al.10 |
Fibrinogen–collagen | MSCs | Successfully demonstrate in-situ printing to repair full thickness skin wounds on the backs of mice | Lee et al.11 |
Extrusion-based | |||
PDMS | Fibroblasts Keratinocytes |
Developed a multilayered epidermal skin layer | Cui and Boland7 |
PCL | HDFs HEKs |
Developed a new 3D cell printing strategy to fabricate a 3D skin tissue model | Zhu and Liang12 |
Laser-assisted | |||
Alginate + blood plasma | Fibroblasts Keratinocytes hMSCs |
Performed accurate positioning of multiple cell types | Lim et al.13 |
Bone and cartilage | |||
Inkjet-based | |||
Fibrin/collagen hydrogel | Chondrocytes | Successfully demonstrated cartilage formation when implanted in mice | Xu et al.14 |
PEGDMA | Chondrocytes | Used FGF-2 and FGF-2/TGF-β1 doped scaffolds for cartilage development | Cui et al.15 |
PEGDMA | Chondrocytes | Demonstrated potential for in-situ printing | Cui et al.16 |
Extrusion-based | |||
Matrigel and alginate | EPCs MSCs |
Observed bone-like formation in the scaffold 6 weeks after implantation in mice | Ozbolat and Hospodiuk17 |
PCL | hASCs | Performed craniofacial regeneration | Bishop et al.18 |
GelMA and HAMa | IPFP cells | Successfully demonstrated reconstruction of chondral defects | Fedorovich et al.19 |
GelMA | Chondrocytes | Cartilaginous tissue was observed after 4 weeks when implanted in mice | Hung et al.20 |
PCL-alginate gel | Chondrocytes | Cartilaginous tissue formation was observed in the scaffold when implanted in subcutaneous spaces of mice | Oussedik et al.21 |
Stereolithography | |||
GelMA and nHA | Osteoblasts hMSCs |
Developed a 3D bone-mimicking model to study metastasis | Zhou et al.22 |
GelMA and collagen type 1 | hMSCs | Developed a method to minimize oxygen inhibition | Tzeng et al.23 |
GelMA + PEGDA + TGF-β1 | hMSCs | Fabricated scaffolds from a precursor hydrolgel, in which cells and nanospheres were suspended | Weiß et al.24 |
Laser-assisted | |||
Sodium alginate | Osteosarcoma cells (MG63) | Evaluated the effect of 3D positioning of cells on PCL biopapers | Morris et al.25 |
N.A. | HUVECs | Performed positioning of enothelial cells within osseous biopapers to induce vascularization | Williams et al.26 |
Neural | |||
Inkjet-based | |||
Phosphate-buffered saline | CHO and rat embryonic motoneurons | Demonstrated successful printing of neural cells using a thermal inkjet printer | Xu et al.27 |
Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium | Primary rat embryonic neurons | Demonstrated that there was no difference in cell survival rate and neurite growth between printed and non-printed cells | Xu et al.28 |
Extrusion-based | |||
PU | NSCs | Repaired damaged nervous system in adult zebra fish | Chung et al.29 |
N.A. | BMSCs | Successfully fabricated purely cellular nerve grafts | Pranzo et al.30; Kundu et al.31 |
Stereolithography | |||
GelMA and graphene nanoplatelets | hNSCs | Fabricated 3D scaffolds with a homogeneous distribution of cells and graphene nanoplatelets | Lu et al.32 |
Corneal | |||
Extrusion-based | |||
Sodium alginate and collagen | Corneal keratinocytes | Demonstrated cell viability of KC remained 90% after day 1 of post printing | Kim et al.33 |
Laser-assisted | |||
Collagen I + recombinant laminin | hESC-LESCs hASCs |
Performed accurate positioning of multiple cell types | Park et al.34 |
Cardiac | |||
Inkjet-based | |||
Alginate | Cardiomyocytes | Successfully printed half heart shape with two connected ventricles, showed contract rhythm under electric stimulation | Lorber et al.35 |
Alginate and gelatin gel | Endothelial cells | Printed tubes, branched tubes, hollow cones, and capillaries with a microscopic porosity | Xu et al.36 |
Fibrin hydrogel | HMVEC | Achieved confluent cell linings with a ring-shaped microvasculature | Nakamura et al.37 |
Sodium alginate | NIH-3T3 | Printed vascular shapes using a liquid support material | Boland et al.38 |
Extrusion-based | |||
GelMA | iPSCs | Developed a microfibrous scaffold capable of spontaneous and synchronous contraction | Hsieh et al.39 |
Me-HA | HAVIC | Printed scaffold began to be remodeled after 3 days in culture | Hsu et al.40 |
Muscular | |||
Extrusion-based | |||
PEGDA and GelMA | NIH-3T3 and C2C12 | Successfully implanted in rats | Dhariwala et al.41 |
Stereolithography | |||
PEGDA | ESCs and C2C12 | Employed dielectrophoresis in cell patterning prior to printing | Pati et al.42 |
Dental | |||
Extrusion-based | |||
GelMA and PEG | PDLSCs | Successfully demonstrated an array of hydrogel with high cell viability of 94% | O’Connell et al.43 |
PCL and β-TCP | – | Successfully demonstrated the reconstruction of maxillary bone defect in a dog | Schuurman et al.44 |
PEG: polyethylene glycol; 3D: three-dimensional; HMVEC: human microvascular endothelial cell; NHDF: neonatal human dermal fibroblast; MSC: mesenchymal stem cell; PDMS: polydimethylsiloxane; PCL: polycaprolactone; HDF: human dermal fibroblast; HEK: human epidermal keratinocyte; PEGDMA: poly(ethylene glycol) dimethacrylate; FGF: fibroblast growth factor; TGF: transforming growth factor; EPC: endothelial progenitor cell; hASC: human adipose–derived stem cell; HAMa: hyaluronic acid-methacrylate; GelMA: gelatin-methacrylamide; IPFP: infrapatellar fat pad; PEGDA: poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate; CHO: Chinese hamster ovary; PU: polyurethane; NSC: neural stem cell; hMSC: human mesenchymal stem cell; BMSC: bone marrow stem cell; hNSC: human neural stem cell; KC: keratinocyte; LESC: limbal epithelial stem cell; TCP: tricalcium phosphate; iPSC: induced pluripotent stem cell; Me-HA: methacrylated hyaluronic acid; HAVIC: human aortic valvular interstitial cell; PDLSC: periodontal ligament stem cell.