Table 1. Comparison of Average Risk Factor Associations for Antisocial Behavior in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs) and High-Income Countries (HICs).
Risk Factor | Strength of Association in LMICs: This Review | Strength of Association in HICs: Prior Reviews |
---|---|---|
Individual-level risk factors: | ||
Prior aggression | Large for aggression | Large for aggression 1 |
Prior conduct problems | Large for conduct problems | Large for conduct problems 2 |
Medium for violence | Medium for violence3 | |
Hyperactivity | Negligible for crime | Small for crime4 |
Poor educational performance | Negligible for intimate partner violence | Small for violence3 |
Drug use | Large for violence | Large for violence 3 |
Early life health risk factors: | ||
Low birth weight | Negligible for conduct problems | Negligible for conduct problems 5 |
Premature birth | Negligible for conduct problems | Negligible for conduct problems 5 |
Child rearing practices: | ||
Maternal authoritarian parenting | Medium for conduct problems & aggression | Medium for conduct problems 2 |
Maternal warmth | Small for conduct problems & aggression | Medium for conduct problems2 |
Maternal authoritative parenting | Medium for conduct problems & aggression | Medium for conduct problems 2 |
Family sociodemographic factors: | ||
Poor family during childhood | Small for conduct problems | Medium for conduct problems 2 |
Small for violence | Small for violence 3 | |
Low maternal education | Small for conduct problems | Large for conduct problems 2 |
Young mother at birth | Small for conduct problems | Small for conduct problems 2 |
Small for violence | Negligible for violence 2 | |
Many siblings | Negligible for violence | Medium for violence 2 |
Note.—Associations are bivariate correlations. The strength of association is described as follows (see Sec. II): negligible, d < 0.10; small, d = 0.10; medium, d = 0.25; large, d = 0.50. References for prior reviews in HICs: 1Olweus (1979); 2Derzon (2010); 3Lipsey and Derzon (1998); 4Tanner-Smith, Wilson, and Lipsey (2013); 5Aarnoudse-Moens et al. (2009). For some risk factors in the current review, described later in the essay, no prior, comparable review was located for studies in HICs.