Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2018 Oct 9.
Published in final edited form as: Crime Justice. 2018 Mar 26;47(1):255–364. doi: 10.1086/696590

Table 1. Comparison of Average Risk Factor Associations for Antisocial Behavior in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs) and High-Income Countries (HICs).

Risk Factor Strength of Association in LMICs: This Review Strength of Association in HICs: Prior Reviews
Individual-level risk factors:
    Prior aggression Large for aggression Large for aggression 1
    Prior conduct problems Large for conduct problems Large for conduct problems 2
Medium for violence Medium for violence3
    Hyperactivity Negligible for crime Small for crime4
    Poor educational performance Negligible for intimate partner violence Small for violence3
    Drug use Large for violence Large for violence 3
Early life health risk factors:
    Low birth weight Negligible for conduct problems Negligible for conduct problems 5
    Premature birth Negligible for conduct problems Negligible for conduct problems 5
Child rearing practices:
    Maternal authoritarian parenting Medium for conduct problems & aggression Medium for conduct problems 2
    Maternal warmth Small for conduct problems & aggression Medium for conduct problems2
    Maternal authoritative parenting Medium for conduct problems & aggression Medium for conduct problems 2
Family sociodemographic factors:
    Poor family during childhood Small for conduct problems Medium for conduct problems 2
Small for violence Small for violence 3
    Low maternal education Small for conduct problems Large for conduct problems 2
    Young mother at birth Small for conduct problems Small for conduct problems 2
Small for violence Negligible for violence 2
    Many siblings Negligible for violence Medium for violence 2

Note.—Associations are bivariate correlations. The strength of association is described as follows (see Sec. II): negligible, d < 0.10; small, d = 0.10; medium, d = 0.25; large, d = 0.50. References for prior reviews in HICs: 1Olweus (1979); 2Derzon (2010); 3Lipsey and Derzon (1998); 4Tanner-Smith, Wilson, and Lipsey (2013); 5Aarnoudse-Moens et al. (2009). For some risk factors in the current review, described later in the essay, no prior, comparable review was located for studies in HICs.