Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 5;12:686. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2018.00686

Table 3.

Music stimuli characterization (presence or absence of lyrics) of all 11 studies included in the ALE meta-analyses.

Year First author Method Sample (N) Contrast Music stimuli Presence of lyrics
2007 Plailly fMRI 13 Familiar music minus unfamiliar Unfamiliar music minus familiar Instrumental music No
2008 Nan fMRI 20 Western vs. Chinese music Melodies No
2008 Watanable fMRI 18 Hits minus CRs Melodies No
2009 Janata fMRI 13 Familiar vs. unfamiliar Top Pop, R&B songs Yes
2009 Klostermann fMRI 16 Hits vs. correct rejections Musical clips with typical timbre and harmonies N.A.
2010 Demorest fMRI 16 Culturally unfamiliar vs. culturally familiar Memory for culturally unfamiliar vs. memory for culturally familiar Instrumental classic music No
2010 Groussard PET 12 Musical semantic > musical reference Tonal melodies No
2011 Pereira fMRI 14 Familiar > unfamiliar Unfamiliar > familiar Pop-rock songs Yes
2014 Altenmuller fMRI 18 Old vs. new pieces New vs. old pieces Symphonic film music No
2015 Sikka fMRI 40 Familiar vs. unfamiliar Melodies from instrumental pieces No
2015 Jacobsen fMRI 32 Long-term known vs. unknown Top 10 songs from 1977- 2007 Yes

N.A., not available.