Table 3.
Music stimuli characterization (presence or absence of lyrics) of all 11 studies included in the ALE meta-analyses.
Year | First author | Method | Sample (N) | Contrast | Music stimuli | Presence of lyrics |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2007 | Plailly | fMRI | 13 | Familiar music minus unfamiliar Unfamiliar music minus familiar | Instrumental music | No |
2008 | Nan | fMRI | 20 | Western vs. Chinese music | Melodies | No |
2008 | Watanable | fMRI | 18 | Hits minus CRs | Melodies | No |
2009 | Janata | fMRI | 13 | Familiar vs. unfamiliar | Top Pop, R&B songs | Yes |
2009 | Klostermann | fMRI | 16 | Hits vs. correct rejections | Musical clips with typical timbre and harmonies | N.A. |
2010 | Demorest | fMRI | 16 | Culturally unfamiliar vs. culturally familiar Memory for culturally unfamiliar vs. memory for culturally familiar | Instrumental classic music | No |
2010 | Groussard | PET | 12 | Musical semantic > musical reference | Tonal melodies | No |
2011 | Pereira | fMRI | 14 | Familiar > unfamiliar Unfamiliar > familiar | Pop-rock songs | Yes |
2014 | Altenmuller | fMRI | 18 | Old vs. new pieces New vs. old pieces | Symphonic film music | No |
2015 | Sikka | fMRI | 40 | Familiar vs. unfamiliar | Melodies from instrumental pieces | No |
2015 | Jacobsen | fMRI | 32 | Long-term known vs. unknown | Top 10 songs from 1977- 2007 | Yes |
N.A., not available.